Policies Make Coherent Care Pathways a Personal Responsibility for Clinicians: A Discourse Analysis of Policy Documents about Coordinators in Hospitals

Abstract

Introduction:In response to increase of patients with complex conditions, policies prescribe measures for improving continuity of care. This study investigates policies introducing coordinator roles in Norwegian hospitals that have proven challenging to implement.Methods:This qualitative study of policy documents employed a discourse analysis inspired by Carol Bacchi’s ‘What‘s the problem represented to be?’. We analysed six legal documents (2011–2016) and selected parts of four whitepapers presenting the statutory patient care coordinator and contact physician roles in hospitals.Results:The ‘problem’ represented in the policies is lack of coherent pathways and lack of stable responsible professionals. Extended personal responsibility for clinical personnel as coordinators is the prescribed solution. Their duties are described in terms of ideals for coherent pathways across conditions and contexts. System measures to support and orchestrate the individual patient’s pathway (e.g. resources, infrastructure) are scarcely addressed.Conclusions and Discussion:We suggest that the policies’ construction of the ‘problem’ as a responsibility issue, result in that neither diversity of patients’ coordination needs, nor heterogeneity of hospital contexts regarding necessary system support for coordinators, is set on the agenda. Adoption of rhetoric from diagnosis-specific standardized pathways obscures unique challenges in creating coherent pathways for patients with complex needs.

Patient Flow or the Patient’s Journey? Exploring Health Care Providers’ Experiences and Understandings of Implementing a Care Pathway to Improve the Quality of Transitional Care for Older People

“…Our findings also suggest that the implementation of a patient-centered care pathway not only relies on health care providers' competencies and efforts. A recent discourse analysis of Norwegian policy on responsibility for good patient pathways highlighted that attention is often on health care providers' competencies and responsibilities and is diverted away from the responsibility of policy makers and organizations (Høyem et al, 2018). Our findings indicate that the health care providers saw the value of putting the patient journey first and trying to incorporate patient logic into care.…”

“…Our findings, however, suggest that they have also become important concerns of health care providers working on the front line. Health care providers are increasingly expected to take on administrative and systems-related responsibilities in addition to their direct patient-related work, often with no change being made to the resources available (Allen, 2009;Høyem et al, 2018). From an institutional logic perspective, this can be seen as public management and market logics pressuring and changing the health care profession logic (Andersson & Liff, 2018;Beedholm & Frederiksen, 2019).…”

Living life with cerebral palsy? A description of the social safety nets for individuals with cerebral palsy in the Nordic countries

“…families with children with disabilities in the nordic countries should have IsPs to guide coordinated and needs-based services. research shows that these plans exist, but are not necessarily used [36][37][38]. According to the national Association of IDs in Iceland (personal communication bryndís snaebjörnsdóttir, 18 march 2020), members find the evaluation of impairment to be inadequate, resulting in fewer, or insufficient, benefits.…”