Policy Analysis of Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Strategies in Canadian Universities – How Far Have We Come?

Abstract

Institutional efforts to address equity, diversity and inclusion in educational settings have been often met with overwhelmingly critical accounts pointing towards well-intentioned attempts that have reinforced exclusion and inequity. A new wave of recent developments among Canadian research-intensive universities (U15) is providing a slightly different account of universities’ involvement in addressing the needs of equity-seeking students. This paper presents data collected through policy analysis of 50 strategic documents from 15 Canadian universities from 2011-2018. The findings suggest that equity, diversity and inclusion activities have become a policy priority attached to a variety of institutional action plans and performance reports. As a result, there has been an increase in institutional strategic activities including institutional political commitment (e.g. new equity offices, new senior administration positions, mandatory training), student and faculty recruitment with programmatic and research supports (e.g. diversity admission policies, scholarships, access programs, curriculum changes), accompanied by broader efforts to create supportive institutional climates (e.g. student advisors, awards, celebrations). Inconsistencies emerged amongst how equity is defined in policy documents, resulting in either redistributive or inclusive practices in equity, diversity, and inclusion initiatives.

Pre‐service teachers' attitudes towards inclusion in Finland

“…To achieve this, all PSTs should get familiar with inclusive education and its core values, and as such understand the principles of equity and equality included in the CRPD. It is also important for teachers to gain disability‐related knowledge and skills as well as strategies to work in inclusive settings (Majoko, 2017; Dally et al ., 2019; Tamtik and Guenter, 2019).…”

Can a Focus on Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Transform Health Service Research?

“…Skepticism and a critical perspective are, therefore, warranted from universities, research institutions, medical journals and funders when considering the much more recent focus on EDI (Tamtik and Guenter 2020). EDI as a concept, process and set of objectives is related to the goals of reducing health inequities, going upstream and tackling the social determinants of health, but is certainly distinct.…”

Responding to COVID-19: Contextual, Pedagogical, and Experiential Considerations from Canadian Northern Postsecondary Educators

“…According to Jeffery (2020), there are ethical principles that must be addressed: transparency, health benefit, efficiency, and adaptability. Educators and senior leadership must reexamine their critical role in ensuring equity and inclusion (Chun and Evans, 2018;Tamtik and Guenter, 2019) as they envision new teaching and learning norms during and after the pandemic.…”