Policy development and implementation in health promotion--from theory to practice: the ADEPT model

Abstract

There is a growing interest among health promotion researchers to better understand and influence the policy process. However, at this point in time, theoretical concepts enabling researchers to do so are still rare and underused, suggesting a need for new, easy-to-use concepts to explain successes or failures of health promotion policies. This article presents the ADEPT (Analysis of Determinants of Policy Impact) approach, which aims to explain and influence policy development and policy impact implementation with four determinants: goals, obligations, resources and opportunities. ADEPT provides a detailed operationalization for both quantitative and qualitative use. An empirical test of the ADEPT model using a quantitative survey of 719 policy-makers from four health promotion policy fields and six European nations indicated that both policy outputs and policy outcomes are influenced by the four determinants. The approach has, in the meantime, been successfully utilized to analyze and initiate policy development in a number of health promotion projects. Despite a number of limitations, ADEPT provides an easy-to-use, theory-based and parsimonious tool for understanding and influencing policy processes in health promotion. Moreover, as it identifies potential 'levers of influence' and can easily be connected to existing methods of community development or capacity building, it is a particularly powerful tool for policy development.

Physical inactivity as a policy problem: applying a concept from policy analysis to a public health issue

“…agenda setting procedures). Several theoretical approaches might be useful in analyzing these processes, for example: i) the Multiple Streams framework [52] which theorizes how policy entrepreneurs may use windows of opportunity to put their issues on the political agenda; ii) the Institutional Rational Choice framework [53] which aims to explain the influence of institutional rules and resources on the behaviour of political actors; iii) the Advocacy Coalition framework [54] which focuses on how coalitions of political actors form around certain policy problems; and iv) the Analysis of Determinants of Policy Impact model [55] which links policy problems to policy determinants and policy outcomes.…”

Institutional and policy issues experienced in the implementation of Botswana's national disability policy

“…In an attempt to explain the basic mechanisms underlying individual human behaviour, von Wright developed a theory about the factors that determine human action and about the logic that underlies the interaction of these factors (Rütten, Gelius, & Abu‐Omar, ). The ADEPT model is an adaptation of von Wright's original theory to the field of health promotion policy.…”

Evidence-based policy revisited: orientation towards the policy process and a public health policy science

“…To achieve this, evidence on determinants of the policy process could be combined with interactive models of knowledge translation (Rütten et al 2010). In particular, we should analyze how knowledge translation can affect key determinants of policy development and policy implementation.…”