Policy Questions: A Conceptual Study

Abstract

A policy question is a request for a fairly stable, but modifiable authoritative line of action aimed at securing an optimal balance between different goods, all of which must be pursued, but cannot be jointly maximized. To such questions there are no purely technical solutions, a point that is revealed by the etiology of policy questions. They appear to arise from conflicts among humans over the distribution of goods, i.e., conflicts of interest. However, the deeper roots of such questions lie not in a conflict of human interests, but in the incompatibility of the actual goods that human beings seek. Policy questions ask how to allocate such goods. But this allocation is the business of politics. No policy without politics nor politics without polity.

Transgender Students in Elementary Schools: How Supportive Principals Lead

“…In the realm of economics, decision making is commonly portrayed as a zero-sum game in which the gains for one group equal losses for other groups (Rozycka-Tran, Boski, & Wojciszke, 2015). In education policy, Green (1994) presents this concept as a matter of “competing goods,” explaining that competing educational priorities, such as excellence and equity, cannot be maximized simultaneously. At the school level, leaders must make decisions about committing resources to some endeavors at the expense of others.…”

Education Reform and the Limits of Policy: Lessons from Michigan

“…In paradise, all values can be pursued simultaneously and without limit, but paradise is destroyed by either of two conditions: inadequate resources or irreconcilable interest or goals-that is, scarcity and conflict. Thus, the essential meaning of the term policy arises from its role in resolving these two fundamental human conditions of scarcity and conflict (Green 1994).…”

Assessing the Connection Between Higher Education Policy and Performance

“…The process of policy making cannot be completely separated from examining the outcomes of a policy nor can those who are involved in defining the rules and championing the policies be separated from examining the outcomes. For example, Green's (1994) explanation of the policy process involves policy analysis, policy formation, policy decision, and political analysis, all of which are separate but overlapping and each of which can inform the other. All of these concepts have implications for our work in South Dakota.…”