Political and Governance Challenges to Achieving Global HIV Goals with Injecting Drug Users: The Case of Pakistan

Abstract

Background: The Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) has recently set the ambitious "90-90-90 target" of having 90% of people living with HIV (PLHIV) know their status, receive antiretroviral therapy (ART), and achieve viral suppression by 2020. This ambitious new goal is occurring in a context of global "scale-down" following nearly a decade of heightened investment in HIV prevention and treatment efforts. Arguably international goals spur action, however, setting unrealistic goals that do not take weak health systems and variations in the nature of the epidemic across countries into consideration may set them up for failure in unproductive ways that lead to a decline in confidence in global governance institutions. This study explores how policy actors tasked with implementing HIV programs navigate the competing demands placed upon them by development targets and national politics, particularly in the current context of waning international investments towards HIV. Methods: To examine these questions, we interviewed 29 key informants comprising health experts in donor organizations and government employees in HIV programs in Pakistan, a country where HIV programs must compete with other issues for attention. Themes were identified inductively through an iterative process and findings were triangulated with various data sources and existing literature. Results: We found both political and governance challenges to achieving the target, particularly in the context of the global HIV scale-down. Political challenges included, low and heterogeneous political commitment for HIV and a conservative legal environment that contributed towards a ban on opiate substitution therapy, creating low treatment coverage. Governance challenges includedstrained state and non-governmental organization (NGO) relations creating a hostile service delivery environment, weak bureaucratic and civil society capacity contributing to poor regulation of the health infrastructure, and resource mismanagement on both the part of the government and NGOs. Conclusion: Our findings suggest that in a context of waning international attention to HIV, policy actors on the ground face a number of practical hurdles to achieving the ambitious targets set out by international agencies. Greater attention to the political and governance challenges of implementing HIV programs in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) could help technical assistance agencies to develop more realistic implementation plans.

Fear, accessibility, and legitimacy: An examination of the effects of political violence on health security in Pakistan

“…Tertiary-level facilities include hospitals (Kumar & Bano, 2017). In 2010, following a major constitutional amendment, the Ministry of Health, alongside 16 other ministries, was devolved to the provinces (Zaidi et al, 2019), which made the provinces responsible for health policy formation, planning, and implementation (Khalid & Ashley, 2019).…”

“…In 2015, Pakistan's out of pocket expenditure, as a percentage of overall health expenditure, was an astounding 67% approximately (The World Bank, 2019). There is also an urban bias in the provision of health services, with out-of-pocket expenditures being much higher for rural households as compared with urban households (Khalid & Sattar, 2016).…”

Governance for injury care systems in Ghana, South Africa and Rwanda: development and pilot testing of an assessment tool

“…Previous studies on health system governance have primarily focused on general health systems functions and particularly on the role of government in governance and the involvement of communities 14. Moreover, the sparse disease-specific literature that exists focuses on the governance of programmes for immunisation,15 TB control,16 mental healthcare17–19 and achieving global HIV goals 20…”

“… 14 Moreover, the sparse disease-specific literature that exists focuses on the governance of programmes for immunisation, 15 TB control, 16 mental healthcare 17–19 and achieving global HIV goals. 20 …”

Pediatric HIV outbreak in Pakistan: policy implications from generalized arima analysis

“…This study will go a long way in assessing the possibility of ending pediatric HIV in the country. Khalid & Fox (2019) investigated how policy actors tasked with implementing HIV programs navigate the competing demands placed upon them by development targets and national policies, particularly in the current context of waning international investments towards HIV. The authors interviewed 29 key informants comprising health experts in donor organizations and government employees in HIV programs in Pakistan.…”