Political–Economic Determinants of External Import Protection under a Preferential Trade Agreement

Abstract

The stalling of WTO multilateralism and the proliferation of preferential trade agreements in recent decades have drawn substantial attention to the impacts of preferential liberalization. A critical question is how they affect the trade barriers imposed against outsiders. I examine the relationship between preferential trade liberalization and protection against non-member countries by testing the predictions of a political–economy model based on the previous literature. Focusing on a specific model allows me to uncover the mechanisms via which preferential liberalization affects external import protection, whereas most of the existing literature has focused on establishing the sign of the effect only. Furthermore, I focus on not only tariffs, as most studies do, but also on the temporary trade barriers of antidumping and safeguards. I test the predictions for Latin America and obtain results that provide solid evidence supporting two mechanisms from the theory, which lead to lower protection against non-members of a preferential trade agreement. First, a lower preferential import protection level means that the increase in preferential imports from increasing the external tariff creates a smaller increase in tariff revenue. Second, as preferential import protection is cut, there is a decrease in the markup and sales of domestic firms, and thus raising the external import protection generates less profit. Moreover, this second effect is present when the political motivation of the government is sufficiently strong.

Do Trade Agreements Enhance Bilateral Trade? Focus on India and Sri Lanka

“…These can pose significant obstacles to trade. Comparative advantage theory suggests that reducing such non-tariff barriers can further enhance trade, especially in sectors where the countries have comparative advantages [41]. Therefore, researchers should investigate whether the agreement has harmonized regulations or reduced these barriers, ultimately fostering more substantial bilateral trade.…”

How Can Tariff Elimination and Trade Facilitation Affect East African Economies?

“…Research on the impacts of preferential liberalisation under WTO multilateralism as well as preferential trade agreements over the past few decades has yielded mixed results. In particular, Tovar (2021) points out that an increase in the external tariff on imports creates a smaller increase in tariff revenue. However, as preferential import protection is reduced, it produces a decrease in the profit margin and sales of domestic firms.…”