Polycentric Solutions for Groundwater Governance in Sub-Saharan Africa: Encouraging Institutional Artisanship in an Extended Ladder of Participation

Abstract

The growth of groundwater irrigation poses opportunities and challenges, particularly in Africa where substantial potential exists for increased groundwater irrigation but has been constrained by limited access to energy, technology for pumps and drilling, markets, and other factors. Conventional groundwater governance concepts for state-led regulation or co-management are problematic for conditions where state capacity or political support for regulation to reconcile conflicting interests is limited. Experience in Africa and elsewhere does offer examples that may help recognize feasible patterns for collective action that can influence the equity, efficiency, and sustainability of groundwater development. An extended ladder of participation helps look beyond state-led water governance and co-management to a more diverse range of opportunities for supporting local autonomy and initiative to expand opportunities and solve problems in groundwater development. Collective action in groundwater governance can include well spacing; sharing of wells, pumps, and pipes; protecting domestic water sources; crop coordination; groundwater recharge; water imports; and aquifer management. Even where non-state organizations and collective action play primary roles in water governance, they may still be empowered by, receive advice from, or share information with government agencies and other actors. Polycentric groundwater governance can be supported by improving information, facilitating cooperation, endorsing standards, providing a legal framework for resolving conflicts and constituting governance agreements, and through polycentric social learning. Polycentric institutional artisanship by water users and their organizations can help find feasible solutions for improving groundwater governance.

Restoring the Commons: A Gendered Analysis of Customary Water Tenure in Sub-Saharan Africa

“…When competition for the same water sources increases, a 'race to the bottom' for groundwater (Bruns 2020) or 'a race to the top' for surface streams risks to take place. In the race to the bottom, the few wealthiest pump owners that drill deepest 'win', at the expensive of all users with shallower wells, including wells used for domestic van Koppen International Journal of the Commons DOI: 10.5334/ijc.1164 purposes.…”

Living customary water tenure in rights-based water management in Sub-Saharan Africa

“…Rules for zoning of new wells at sufficient distance avoid future competition, but may be difficult to enforce. Moving to less water demanding crops is another common strategy used (Bruns 2021).…”

Defining Pathways towards African Ecological Futures

“…For instance, new institutional structures such as water user associations, which are increasingly being formalised across Africa, allow local communities to co-manage their own resources through polycentric governance with help from civil society, government and the private sector [109]. At a different scale, the "Nile Basin Initiative" is an example of a multi-country, multi-partner initiative that presents a platform facilitating discussions around the effective management of water and other resources in the Nile basin, promoting stability and sustainable resource governance [110].…”