Poor Decision Making Is a Consequence of Cognitive Decline among Older Persons without Alzheimer’s Disease or Mild Cognitive Impairment

Abstract

ObjectiveDecision making is an important determinant of health and well-being across the lifespan but is critical in aging, when many influential decisions are made just as cognitive function declines. Increasing evidence suggests that older adults, even those without dementia, often make poor decisions and are selectively vulnerable to scams. To date, however, the factors associated with poor decision making in old age are unknown. The objective of this study was to test the hypothesis that poor decision making is a consequence of cognitive decline among older persons without Alzheimer’s disease or mild cognitive impairment.MethodsParticipants were 420 non-demented persons from the Memory and Aging Project, a longitudinal, clinical-pathologic cohort study of aging in the Chicago metropolitan area. All underwent repeated cognitive evaluations and subsequently completed assessments of decision making and susceptibility to scams. Decision making was measured using 12 items from a previously established performance-based measure and a self-report measure of susceptibility to scams.ResultsCognitive function data were collected over an average of 5.5 years prior to the decision making assessment. Regression analyses were used to examine whether the prior rate of cognitive decline predicted the level of decision making and susceptibility to scams; analyses controlled for age, sex, education, and starting level of cognition. Among 420 persons without dementia, more rapid cognitive decline predicted poorer decision making and increased susceptibility to scams (p’s<0.001). Further, the relations between cognitive decline, decision making and scams persisted in analyses restricted to persons without any cognitive impairment (i.e., no dementia or even mild cognitive impairment).ConclusionsPoor decision making is a consequence of cognitive decline among older persons without Alzheimer’s disease or mild cognitive impairment, those widely considered “cognitively healthy.” These findings suggest that even very subtle age-related changes in cognition have detrimental effects on judgment.

Financial decision-making abilities and financial exploitation in older African Americans: Preliminary validity evidence for the Lichtenberg Financial Decision Rating Scale (LFDRS)

“…Boyle et al (2012) and Boyle (2013) examined how cognitive abilities before dementia onset predicted financial decision making five years later, and found that more rapid cognitive decline lead to poorer decision-making abilities (hypothetical mutual fund options), even in participants with Mild Cognitive Impairment. These results are consistent with Marson et al’s (2009) program of research on the Financial Capacity Instrument.…”

Psychological and Functional Vulnerability Predicts Fraud Cases in Older Adults: Results of a Longitudinal Study

“…Boyle et al (2012) and Bryan, Boyle, and Bennett (2014) developed a five-item measure of fraud susceptibility for older adults that assesses how frequently older adults report feeling obligated to answer the phone, having trouble ending phone calls, or believing things that sound too good to be true. Boyle et al examined 420 non-demented older adults from the Rush University Memory and Aging Project at baseline and 5-year follow-up.…”

The Lichtenberg Financial Decision Screening Scale (LFDSS): A new tool for assessing financial decision making and preventing financial exploitation

“…Other researchers have measured aspects of elders’ financial decision-making ability through assessment of financial literacy and hypothetical scenarios (Boyle et al, 2012; James, Boyle, Bennett, & Bennett, 2012). Financial literacy is interpreted as the ability to perform simple calculations (e.g., add up purchases and interest rates) and knowledge of financial concepts such as stocks, bonds, and compound interest, which the authors acknowledge may not apply to seniors with limited education (Boyle et al, 2012). Hypothetical financial situations are designed to simulate (a) the resources and documents used in real-world financial settings (e.g.…”