Bullheads Ameiurus spp. are found throughout much of the United States and are infrequently studied species. Although limited information has been published on the Black Bullhead A. melas and Yellow Bullhead A. natalis, it has been shown that bullheads can dominate the fish biomass in some north temperate U.S. lakes, resulting in a fish community exclusive of Walleye Sander vitreus and Yellow Perch Perca flavescens. Recently, recruitment and abundances of popular coolwater sport fishes, such as Walleye and Yellow Perch, have been declining in some northern Wisconsin lakes. These observed declines, coupled with high bullhead densities, led fisheries biologists to conduct whole‐lake bullhead removals on four northern Wisconsin lakes. Removal of Black and Yellow bullheads from these lakes resulted in substantial changes in the fish communities. The CPUE of naturally reproduced age‐0 Walleye increased in Lake Metonga and Patten Lake following the removal of bullheads. Additionally, survival of stocked Walleye increased in Crane and Pickerel lakes after bullhead removals, resulting in higher CPUE of age‐0 and age‐1 Walleye. Subsequently, adult Walleye abundance has increased or remained steady in all bullhead removal lakes. Significant declines in abundance of Bluegill Lepomis macrochirus and increases in abundance of Yellow Perch and Black Crappie Pomoxis nigromaculatus were also observed after bullhead removals, further illustrating a shift in fish community composition. Our observations suggest that when at high densities, bullheads can play a significant role in structuring fish communities and the removal of bullheads can increase recruitment, survival, and abundance of sport fishes like Walleye and Yellow Perch.