Populism and Carbon Tax Justice: The Yellow Vest Movement in France

Abstract

Scholars cite right-wing authoritarian and business-elite influences in their explanations of populist mobilization against climate reforms. The Yellow Vest movement in France, initially sparked by opposition to a carbon tax, defies the generalizations offered by scholars, the media, and politicians alike. This populist movement emerged from below rather than from elite sponsorship and was motivated by social justice concerns. Through in-depth interviews with 31 Yellow Vest activists as well as supplementary primary texts and data, I uncover how the activists frame carbon taxation and climate change within their political struggle. The findings are four-fold: 1) the Yellow Vests are concerned about global climate change and feel their anti-climate depictions in the media are rooted in a government strategy to divide and discredit the movement; 2) they view the government’s taxing them in order to fight climate change as corrupt and unfair; 3) they argue that the carbon tax is additionally unjust due to their precarity, which has increased over several decades; 4) they want to fight climate change on their own terms and argue for more direct forms of democracy to equalize decision making. I conclude with a framework for understanding how and why popular movements oppose climate reforms.

Comparative Green Advantage: Growth Regimes and Public Investment in Renewable Energy R&D

“…Though the EU is a global leader on climate change and member states generally comply with environmental regulations (Börzel and Buzogány, 2019), the EU has also experienced substantial challenges to climate governance. There are high tensions between national and supranational environmental interests (Driscoll, 2021b; Zito, 2005), EU institutions increasingly outsource environmental enforcement to nongovernmental organizations (Hofmann, 2019) and nationalist movements like the United Kingdom's withdrawal from the EU (Brexit) undermine climate reforms at both the EU and national levels (Burns et al, 2019). My findings suggest that challenges in climate governance are, in part, due to the asymmetries amongst European growth regimes.…”

Absorptive Resisting Work: How the yellow vests deployed resistance to and through violence

“…However, many actors came from the working and lower-middle class, experienced day-to-day economic difficulties, were in debt, and felt excluded from political institutions (Bantigny, 2019). Hence, although initially about opposing the gas tax, the movement’s grievances encompassed broader topics, such as purchasing power, social and fiscal justice, or the implementation of participatory democratic practices and control of representatives (Collectif d’enquête sur les Gilets Jaunes, 2019; Driscoll, 2023; Jeanpierre, 2019). The French government initially answered various yellow vest claims.…”

Public support for carbon tax in South Korea: The role of tax design and revenue recycling

“…Income tax reduction was the chosen method of revenue recycling in Finland and Sweden, while France operates corporate tax reduction. This suggests that national political contexts in legislating carbon tax vary from one another, effectively diverging into different 'types' of carbon tax, or akin to comparing 'welfare states' (Driscoll, 2023).…”