A woman aged 54 was studied because of a severe acute porphyric (neurologic) relapse with clinical and chemical findings characteristic of porphyria variegate. During a family survey, her brother, aged 59, was found to have chemical abnormalities typical of porphyria cutanea tarda, without suggestion of neurologic manifestations. He had mild skin changes compatible with either of these forms of porphyria. The sister exhibited the protocoproporphyria of porphyria variegata, together with a large amount of fecal "x"9 porphyrin fraction, without demonstrable isocoproporphyrins. The brother had a uro-isocopro-type of porphyria in accord with the diagnosis of porphyria cutanea tarda, and quite at variance with the sister's findings. This occurrence of porphyria variegata and porphyria cutanea tarda in siblings is thus far unique. Certain hypotheses are considered in respect to genetic aspects of the differing porphyrias in this sib ing pair.Porphyria cutanea tarda (PCT) and porphyria variegata (PV) are now generally recognized as entirely independent forms of porphyria. The genetic character of the latter is overt, that of the former relatively occult. PV was first known and is still at times referred to as South African genetic porphyria; while PCT has commonly been designated as "symptomatic" or "acquired." Nevertheless, we have observed PCT in 27 of 67 members examined, in 11 families (C. J. Watson, K. Ahmed, I. Bossenmaier, and R. Cardinal, in preparation). The same study reveals many other instances of familial occurrence in the literature. In addition to the foregoing families, 74 "sporadic" cases of PCT, apparently nonfamilial, were represented in the same roster of 464 cases of porphyria of all types observed since 1938. The relative infrequence of familial in contrast to "sporadic" PCT has often been ascribed to low penetrance of an autosomal dominant gene, and the phenotypic manifestations to "revealing" factors, notably alcohol, estrogens, iron overload, immunologic disturbances, and certain others (G. Gulmen, R. Cardinal, I. Bossenmaier, Z. J. Petryka, and C. J.
Watson, in preparation).The present report describes a sister and brother, the former studied first because of an almost fatal acute neurologic relapse related to chemically typical PV; the latter found to have outspoken chemical evidence of PCT with very mild cutaneous manifestations to which little attention had been given.CASE PROTOCOLS P430, female, 54, German-American ancestry. Admitted to Northwestern Hospital, Minneapolis, on November 16, 1971, in extremis, with quadriplegia, respiratory paralysis, and vagal involvement including marked tachycardia and laryngeal weakness. Further clinical details are to be described separately.The Watson-Schwartz test for porphobilinogen (1), carried out in the local hospital, was strongly positive, confirming the suspected diagnosis of acute porphyria.She was transferred to this hospital and unit because of profound respiratory difficulty for which a tracheostomy with assisted respiration became ne...