Nonclassical correlations known as entanglement, quantum discord, quantum deficit, measurement-induced disturbance, quantum Maxwell's demon, etc., may provide novel insights into quantum-information processing, quantumthermodynamics processes, open-system dynamics, quantum molecular dynamics, and general quantum chemistry. We study a new effect of quantumness of correlations accompanying collision of two distinguishable quantum systems A and B, the latter being part of a larger (interacting) system B 1 D. In contrast to the common assumption of a classical environment or "demon" D, the quantum case exhibits striking new qualitative features. Here, in the context of incoherent inelastic neutron scattering from H-atoms which create molecular excitations (vibration, rotation, translation), we report theoretical and experimental evidence of a new phenomenon: a considerably reduced effective mass of H, or equivalently, an anomalous momentum-transfer deficit in the neutron-H collision. These findings contradict conventional theoretical expectations even qualitatively, but find a straightforward interpretation in the new theoretical frame under consideration.