Post-Occupancy Evaluation of Pagerjurang Permanent Housing After the Merapi Volcanic Eruption

Setiadia, Amos; Andriessen, Anouck; Anisa, Refranisa

doi:10.3846/jau.2020.11265

Cited by 6 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 12 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…This ensures that the houses are not merely visually pleasing, but also functionally suitable to increase residential satisfaction and overall well-being. Furthermore, in line with multiple studies [11,14,22,26,31,38,59,81,82], the study identified dissatisfaction among resettled households regarding the layout of permanent houses in resettlement. The findings of this study are consistent with previous research conducted by several researchers [23,26,32,59], highlighting that the houses in Panipokhari also overlooked the need for space for addition and modification, a crucial factor for housing satisfaction.…”

Section: Discussionsupporting

confidence: 56%

Factors Influencing Housing Satisfaction in Post-Disaster Resettlement: A Case of Nepal

Shrestha,

Uprety,

Pokharel

2023

Sustainability

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Housing satisfaction, crucial for sustainable post-disaster resettlement housing, has received limited attention in research. This study aimed to identify households’ perceived importance of housing satisfaction factors and their significance in post-disaster resettlement housing programs. Focusing on Nepal’s Panipokhari Integrated Settlement after the 2015 Gorkha earthquake, it identified relatively significant housing satisfaction factors using mean satisfaction scores, the relative importance index, and Spearman rank correlation. The data were derived from a structured questionnaire survey, complemented by field observations, measurement, and semi-structured qualitative interviews that support the findings. The study found key housing satisfaction factors as need-based housing design (r = 0.70), layout (r = 0.74), modification flexibility (r = 0.70), utility spaces such as kitchen gardens and cattle sheds (r = 0.67), house completeness (r = 0.80), thermal comfort (r = 0.63), and social and cultural aspects such as traditional hearths (r = 0.72) and spaces for rituals and events (r = 0.77). The study concluded that the integration of these factors in the policy-making, planning, and design is important for successful resettlement housing outcomes in regions with comparable socio-cultural and economic backgrounds. The study has practical significance and, thus, will help policy-makers, implementers, and researchers aiming for successful and sustainable resettlement outcomes.

show abstract

Section: Discussionsupporting

confidence: 56%

Factors Influencing Housing Satisfaction in Post-Disaster Resettlement: A Case of Nepal

Shrestha,

Uprety,

Pokharel

2023

Sustainability

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…The developed core house can be expanded by repeating a structural frame that is modular and directed by the design to accommodate the development [13]. In the Pagerjurang post-reconstructed housing evaluation, Wulansari (2014) and Setiadi et al ( 2020) studied the interrelation aspects of old and new spaces, the role of government in resettlement efforts and inhabitants' involvement through the social, economic and culture sectors [11] [14].…”

Section: Post-disaster Housing Reconstruction Policymentioning

confidence: 99%

Sustainable development study of the post-disaster housing resettlement case in Yogyakarta Province, Indonesia case study: Nglepen Village and Pagerjurang Village

Setyonugroho,

Maki

2024

IOP Conf. Ser.: Earth Environ. Sci.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

According to Government Regulation No. 21 of 2008, chapter 67, article 3, the Government of Indonesia promotes community involvement in the post-disaster housing recovery act. The resettlement case in Nglepen Village and Pagerjurang Village is categorized as a rapid and massive recovery based on a contractor-based strategy due to limited land availability, budgetary constraints, post-disaster emergency conditions, and the government’s responsibility to provide large numbers of sufficient housing units. In specific circumstances, the condition of the relocation houses will typically not be able to meet the needs of most residents. This study emphasized the sustainable development of the two case studies and highlighted different private residential housing types: 1) a dome-shaped reinforced structure house in Nglepen and 2) a conventional reinforced concrete structural frame house in Pagerjurang. The two different structural housing system types will affect the sustainable development of the housing condition. Field surveys and interviews were conducted in 2022–2023 to collect the primary data, and study of literacy was used to support the findings and analyzed through a descriptive qualitative method. The sustainable development in the case study relocation area is mainly influenced by aspects such as the economic sector, development priorities related to the residents’ activities and needs, and the adaptive design strategy between old and new buildings. According to the disaster management law and derivative regulations, the Government of Indonesia has sought ideal conditions for disaster-affected residents in the relocation and reconstruction processes. The study’s conclusions suggested that the government, beneficiaries, and all stakeholders must collaborate to improve post-disaster housing and settlement relocation planning and reconstruction in the future by involving the residents in the process of deciding on the location, managing the development, and creating comprehensively sustainable development guidelines for the people’s houses and its living environment.

show abstract

“…As a result, the people of Kepuharjo Village need new settlements. For this reason, Pagerjurang permanent shelter is one of the post-Merapi relocations built by the Government and Rekompak to meet the needs of the victims of the eruption (Setiadi et al, 2020). The sudden movement of people due to the disaster to the Pagerjurang permanent shelter caused the Kepuharjo community to require adjustments to their housing patterns in new settlements.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

The Value of Gotong-royong in the Mountainous Settlement of Kepuharjo Village at Pagerjurang Permanent Shelter in Yogyakarta, Indonesia

2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Providing housing for refugees due to disasters is a common problem in countries prone to natural disasters. The eruption of Mount Merapi in Yogyakarta in 2010 has displaced the people of Kepuharjo Village to a new settlement in Pagerjurang permanent shelter. However, the process of settling in a new settlement requires adjustments because the people of Kepuharjo Village have been living on the slopes of Mount Merapi for generations. This research is a qualitative research which aims to find a reflection of the space-occupancy value system that occurs in the village of Kepuharjo at the Pagerjurang permanent shelter. The results of observations and interviews with 29 units show that the description of the activities and arrangement of the residential space in the Pagerjurang permanent shelter. The results showed that the motivation for the development of residential spaces is closely related to kinship and socio-cultural values in the daily life of the occupants. The socio-cultural reflection on the residential space of the Kepuharjo community in the Pagerjurang permanent shelter is in line with the social principles of mutual-cooperation (gotong-royong). Gotong-royong is expressed in the strengthening of space, expansion of space, and agreement of space.

show abstract

Post-Occupancy Evaluation of Pagerjurang Permanent Housing After the Merapi Volcanic Eruption

Cited by 6 publications

References 12 publications

Factors Influencing Housing Satisfaction in Post-Disaster Resettlement: A Case of Nepal

Factors Influencing Housing Satisfaction in Post-Disaster Resettlement: A Case of Nepal

Sustainable development study of the post-disaster housing resettlement case in Yogyakarta Province, Indonesia case study: Nglepen Village and Pagerjurang Village

The Value of Gotong-royong in the Mountainous Settlement of Kepuharjo Village at Pagerjurang Permanent Shelter in Yogyakarta, Indonesia

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About