Postgraduate Orthodontics Students’ and Mentors’ Perceptions of Portfolios and Discussion as Tools for Development of Reflection

Abstract

The aim of this study was to analyze the effects of a portfolio learning strategy designed to develop students' reflection abilities in a postgraduate orthodontic program in the UK. Nine first-year postgraduate orthodontic students and seven mentors participated in the one-year program, which included a reflective portfolio, mentorship, and discussion. After the program, the students' and mentors' perceptions were collected using focus groups and individual interviews, respectively. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis. Four categories emerged. The first, reflection, was considered a skill to learn, and time was needed for students to fully understand its meaning and achieve its outcomes. The second theme, characteristics of reflection, was descriptive at the beginning and more critical at the end of the experience. The third theme, outcomes of reflection, involved students' improved problem-solving and action-planning abilities and increased self-awareness, motivation, confidence, and communication skills. In the fourth theme, stimulation of reflection, students did not agree with mentors regarding the importance of reflective writing, but they recognized the value of the portfolio's reflective log in facilitating the reflective process. There was greater agreement between students and mentors regarding discussions with mentors and among peers as tools to achieve higher levels of reflection. Overall, these students and mentors considered the strategy an effective tool for improving students' reflection.Dr. Tonni is Researcher,

Experiences of recent graduates: reframing reflection as purposeful, social activity

“…Commitment from the profession is necessary to bring about change in culture and working circumstances, supporting collaborative reflective activity and development and offering opportunities to identify new perspectives and further development needs 3 44 . Recent literature has described the importance of collaborative reflective activity through mentoring, 52 53 group discussions 3 54 55 and subsequent discussion of written reflections 53 56–59 . Despite encouragement in the PDP Guidance that employers should provide mentorship and support while graduates complete the PDR, the data from the participants in this study and others indicate that it is not happening consistently within small animal practice 8 11…”

E-portfolio system development for undergraduate clinical dentistry: An action research study in one university

“…It made me realize that I needed to learn and practice more." (ID 2-p. [3][4][5] Students understood more about the steps and advantages of conducting self-reflection. Students valued the prompts of self-reflection included in the platform.…”

Dental students’ experience of conscious sedation: A qualitative review of student reflections

“…The need for student training in reflective practice to facilitate life‐long learning and continued clinical competency has been highlighted 3 . Reflective practise has been recognised as integral to “good practice" within healthcare education 30‐37 . Limited evidence suggests that reflection improves the quality of care directly through clinical competence but its benefits can enhance care delivery through increased problem‐solving, confidence and communication 30,32,38 …”