Potential Benefits and Harms of a Peer Support Social Network Service on the Internet for People With Depressive Tendencies: Qualitative Content Analysis and Social Network Analysis

Abstract

BackgroundInternet peer support groups for depression are becoming popular and could be affected by an increasing number of social network services (SNSs). However, little is known about participant characteristics, social relationships in SNSs, and the reasons for usage. In addition, the effects of SNS participation on people with depression are rather unknown.ObjectiveThe aim was to explore the potential benefits and harms of an SNS for depression based on a concurrent triangulation design of mixed methods strategy, including qualitative content analysis and social network analysis.MethodsA cross-sectional Internet survey of participants, which involved the collection of SNS log files and a questionnaire, was conducted in an SNS for people with self-reported depressive tendencies in Japan in 2007. Quantitative data, which included user demographics, depressive state, and assessment of the SNS (positive vs not positive), were statistically analyzed. Descriptive contents of responses to open-ended questions concerning advantages and disadvantages of SNS participation were analyzed using the inductive approach of qualitative content analysis. Contents were organized into codes, concepts, categories, and a storyline based on the grounded theory approach. Social relationships, derived from data of “friends,” were analyzed using social network analysis, in which network measures and the extent of interpersonal association were calculated based on the social network theory. Each analysis and integration of results were performed through a concurrent triangulation design of mixed methods strategy.ResultsThere were 105 participants. Median age was 36 years, and 51% (36/71) were male. There were 37 valid respondents; their number of friends and frequency of accessing the SNS were significantly higher than for invalid/nonrespondents (P = .008 and P = .003). Among respondents, 90% (28/31) were mildly, moderately, or severely depressed. Assessment of the SNS was performed by determining the access frequency of the SNS and the number of friends. Qualitative content analysis indicated that user-selectable peer support could be passive, active, and/or interactive based on anonymity or ease of use, and there was the potential harm of a downward depressive spiral triggered by aggravated psychological burden. Social network analysis revealed that users communicated one-on-one with each other or in small groups (five people or less). A downward depressive spiral was related to friends who were moderately or severely depressed and friends with negative assessment of the SNS.ConclusionsAn SNS for people with depressive tendencies provides various opportunities to obtain support that meets users’ needs. To avoid a downward depressive spiral, we recommend that participants do not use SNSs when they feel that the SNS is not user-selectable, when they get egocentric comments, when friends have a negative assessment of the SNS, or when they have additional psychological burden.

You Get What You Give: Understanding Reply Reciprocity and Social Capital in Online Health Support Forums

“…It is estimated that, globally, more than 350 million people of all ages suffer from depression (World Health Organization, 2016). For individuals experiencing depressive symptoms, online support forums can serve as important venues through which they can obtain support from others to cope with their health condition (Takahashi et al, 2009). In light of the increasing cost of health care that people are facing today (Mills, 2016), peer support in the form of mutual sharing of information and experiences is a viable strategy for individuals to cope with health issues such as depression (Dennis, 2003).…”

Cognitive Theories of Depression in Online Peer Support Forums: Exploring the Cognitive Triad

“…the Cognitive Distortions Scale (Briere, 2000) alongside qualitative analysis. Finally, it is accepted that those with depressive symptoms may favour using online facilities due to the controllability and low social expectations of the environment (Takahashi et al, 2009). However, remote interaction with peers may encourage social isolation, negative rumination and depression itself, with the potential for internet addiction in the study sample to confound observations (Bermas, Ghaziyani, & Ebad Asgari, 2013).…”

“…Griffiths et al, 2012;Morris, Schueller, & Picard, 2015). Such studies present mixed findings regarding the utility of OF, with Lawlor & Kirakowski (2014) highlighting the detrimental effects of overdependency, and Takahashi et al (2009) reporting ease of use as a benefit for users.…”

Facebook users' intentions in risk communication and food-safety issues

“…Social support Lochner, Kawachi, and Kennedy (1999) suggest that social support is a feature of the social structure, not of the individual actors within the social structure. Individuals seek social support when facing difficult times, such as serious illness (Takahashi et al, 2009). During a risk or disaster, social media provide latent functions of social support (Macias, Hilyard, & Freimuth, 2009;Perez-Lugo, 2004;Thelwell & Stuart, 2007).…”

“…Extant literature examines the use of social media on building public relations (Alikilic & Atabek, 2012;Briones, Kuch, Liu, & Jin, 2011;Verhoeven, Tench, Zerfass, Moreno, & Verdid, 2012), developing strategic risk communication (Bardus, 2011;Liu, Austin, & Jin, 2011;Schultza, Utza, & Goritzb, 2011) and marketing products (Christodoulides, Jevons, & Bonhomme, 2012). Social media become new tools to share risk information (Takahashi et al, 2009). They also makes risk communication easier and more efficient and allows the users to share the message or leave a message (Anderson, Rainey, & Eysenbach, 2003;Bass et al, 2006).…”