Potential environmental benefits from woodfuel transitions in Haiti: Geospatial scenarios to 2027

Abstract

Woodfuels constitute nearly 80% of Haiti's primary energy supply. Forests are severely degraded and the nation has long been considered an archetypal case of woodfuel-driven deforestation. However, there is little empirical evidence that woodfuel demand directly contributes to deforestation, but may contribute to degradation. We use MoFuSS (Modeling Fuelwood Sustainability Scenarios), a dynamic landscape model, to assess whether current woodfuel demand is as impactful as it is often depicted by simulating changes in land cover that would result if current demand continues unabated. We also simulate several near-term interventions focused on woodfuel demand reduction to analyze the land cover impacts of different energy trajectories. We find that current demand may contribute to moderate levels of degradation, but it is not as severe as is typically portrayed. Under a business-as-usual scenario, the simulated regenerative capacity of woody biomass is insufficient to meet Haiti's increasing demand for wood energy and, as a result, between 2017 and 2027 stocks of above-ground (woody) biomass could decline by 4% ± 1%. This is an annual loss of 302 ± 29 kton of wood and would emit 555 ± 54 kton CO 2 yr −1 . Aggressive interventions to reduce woodfuel demand could slow or even reverse woodfuel-driven degradation, allowing woody biomass to recover in some regions. We discuss the policy implications and propose steps to reduce uncertainty and validate the model.

Fuelwood use patterns in Rural Mexico: a critique to the conventional energy transition model

“…Recent developments in this area include Woodfuel Integrated Supply/Demand Overview Mapping (WISDOM) and Modeling Fuelwood Saving Scenarios (MoFuSS) models, which have been applied in several regions of the world and at different geographic scales -from pantropical to landscape level analysis (e.g. Bailis et al, 2015;Ghilardi, Tarter & Bailis, 2018).…”

Using machine learning to make government spending greener

“…A primary driver of deforestation in Haiti is the demand for fuelwood, which makes up almost 80 per cent of Haiti's primary energy supply [18,19]. This demand is driven, in turn, by subpar electrical and power infras- tructure, driving people to turn to woodfuels as alternative energy sources [20].…”

Risk management and decision-making in relation to sustainable development

“…Reducing emissions of black carbon alongside GHG reductions offers immediate health co-benefits (Shindell et al 2012;Pandey et al 2017;Weyant et al 2019a;Sparrevik et al 2015). Significant GHG emissions reductions, depending on baseline or reference use, can be obtained through fuel-switching to gaseous and liquid fuels, sustainable harvesting of woodfuels, upgrading to efficient stoves, and adopting high-quality processed fuels such as wood pellets (medium evidence, high agreement) (Wathore et al 2017;Jagger and Das 2018;Quinn et al 2018;Cutz et al 2017b;Carter et al 2018;Ghilardi et al 2018;Weyant et al 2019b;Hoffmann et al 2015b).…”