“…With regard to Conceptualizing and/or designing circular production systems, we called for 'Circular production systems, such as aquaponics, integrated multi-trophic aquaculture systems, etc.'. For this topic, four interesting reviews emerged, one relevant for marine aquaculture, 18 two relevant for inland aquaculture 19 and one for both. 20,21 Some lesser known approaches were taken to the forefront by Garibay-Valtez et al, 20 Lothmann and Sewilam, 18 and Zhao et al, 21 while promising solutions were revisited from a wider industry perspective by Marousek et al 19 With regard to Reduce, the call stipulated 'Reducing emissions and footprints of aquaculture' which was complemented by Arantzamendia et al 22 exploring the feasibility of bio-based solutions for innovations in materials used in aquaculture as a possible emerging new science field.…”