Background/Objectives: Glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) receptor is currently one of the most explored targets exploited for the management of diabetes and obesity, with many aspects of its mechanisms behind cardiovascular protection yet to be fully elucidated. Research dedicated towards the development of oral GLP-1 therapy and non-peptide ligands with broader clinical applications is crucial towards unveiling the full therapeutic capacity of this potent class of medicines. Methods: This study describes the virtual screening of a natural product database consisting of 695,133 compounds for positive GLP-1 allosteric modulation. The database, obtained from the Coconut website, was filtered according to a set of physicochemical descriptors, then was shape screened against the crystal ligand conformation. This filtered database consisting of 26,325 compounds was used for virtual screening against the GLP-1 allosteric site. Results: The results identified ten best hits with the XP score ranging from −9.6 to −7.6 and MM-GBSA scores ranging from −50.8 to −32.4 and another 58 hits from docked pose filter and a second round of XP docking and MM-GBSA calculation followed by molecular dynamics. The analysis of results identified hits from various natural products (NPs) classes, to whom attributed antidiabetic and anti-obesity effects have been previously reported. The results also pointed to β-lactam antibiotics that may be evaluated in drug repurposing studies for off-target effects. The calculated ADMET properties for those hits revealed suitable profiles for further development in terms of bioavailability and toxicity. Conclusion: The current study identified several NPs as potential GLP-1 positive allosteric modulators and revealed common structural scaffolds including peptidomimetics, lactams, coumarins, and sulfonamides with peptidomimetics being the most prominent especially in indole and coumarin cores.