Practical compassions: repertoires of practice and compassion talk in acute mental healthcare

Abstract

This article reports an exploratory study of the concept of compassion in the work of 20 mental health practitioners in a UK Midlands facility. Using notions of practice derived from phenomenology and Bourdieusian sociology and notions of emotional labour we identify two contrasting interpretive repertoires in discussions of compassion. The first, the practical compassion repertoire, evokes the practical, physical and bodily aspects of compassion. It involves organising being with patients, playing games, anticipating disruption and taking them outside for cigarettes. Practitioners described being aware that these practical, bodily activities could lead to patients 'opening up', disclosing their interior concerns and enabling practical, compassionate mental health work to take place. In contrast, the second, organisational repertoire, concerns organisational constraints on compassionate practice. The shortage of staff, the record-keeping and internal processes of quality control were seen as time-greedy and apt to detract from contact with patients. The findings are discussed in relation to Bourdieu and Merleau-Ponty's phenomenological accounts of practice and habit and set in context in the growing interest in placing compassion centrally in healthcare. We also explore how the exercise of compassion in the way our participants describe it can afford the more effective exercise of medical power.

Community mental health nurses' and compassion: an interpretative approach

“…) making care more person‐centred (McCormack & McCance ) and therefore recovery‐focused (Brown et al . ). The studies by Spandler & Stickley () and Brown et al .…”

Shame and the vulnerable self in medical contexts: the compassionate solution

“…It is a mistake to believe that compassion fatigue arises because we are constantly engaging with suffering. Although it can, it more commonly arises from the constant battle to provide the service one wants to provide 46. Rarely do clinicians give ‘distress caused by interacting with patients’ as a reason for compassion fatigue.…”

Why and how is compassion necessary to provide good quality healthcare?

“…Gilbert and Choden (7) define compassion as the "sensitivity to suffering in self and others with a commitment to try to alleviate and prevent it". Drawing on psychological literature their primary focus is on the motivation of individuals (8) but for healthcare professionals compassion is more about relational interpersonal practice (9). There is evidence that being cared for by compassionate clinicians increases and speeds up recovery (8).…”