“…The birth of the Society has been described as the logical culmination of a social and intellectual trajectory which sees interests and overlapping memberships flowing through the British Mineralogical Society, the Askesian Society and the Geological Society (Weindling 1979(Weindling , 1983Torrens 2009;Veneer 2009). The ephemeral nature of these earlier incarnations of a 'geological' society is important to understanding the growing possibilities for socialized participation in this emerging field, but we cannot say that one begat the other.…”