Practices of Weight Regulation Among Elite Athletes in Combat Sports: A Matter of Mental Advantage?

Abstract

Context The combination of extensive weight loss and inadequate nutritional strategies used to lose weight rapidly for competition in weight-category sports may negatively affect athletic performance and health. Objective To explore the reasoning of elite combat-sport athletes about rapid weight loss and regaining of weight before competitions. Design Qualitative study. Setting With grounded theory as a theoretical framework, we employed a cross-examinational approach including interviews, observations, and Internet sources. Sports observations were obtained at competitions and statements by combat-sport athletes were collected on the Internet. Patients or Other Participants Participants in the interviews were 14 Swedish national team athletes (9 men, 5 women; age range, 18 to 36 years) in 3 Olympic combat sports (wrestling, judo, and taekwondo). Data Collection and Analysis Semistructured interviews with 14 athletes from the Swedish national teams in wrestling, judo, and taekwondo were conducted at a location of each participant's choice. The field observations were conducted at European competitions in these 3 sports. In addition, interviews and statements made by athletes in combat sports were collected on the Internet. Results Positive aspects of weight regulation other than gaining physical advantage emerged from the data during the analysis: sport identity, mental diversion, and mental advantage. Together and individually, these categories point toward the positive aspects of weight regulation experienced by the athletes. Practicing weight regulation mediates a self-image of being “a real athlete.” Weight regulation is also considered mentally important as a part of the precompetition preparation, serving as a coping strategy by creating a feeling of increased focus and commitment. Moreover, a mental advantage relative to one's opponents can be gained through the practice of weight regulation. Conclusions Weight regulation has mentally important functions extending beyond the common notion that combat-sport athletes reduce their weight merely to gain a physical edge over their opponents.

Effect of educational training on nutrition and weight control in under-18 Spanish wrestlers

“…A uniform message is needed that stresses that this protocol must be considered as part of the old, unhealthy training style. Indeed, several studies have shown that these behaviors reduce the wrestler's physical and technical abilities to compete [30][31][32] . If changes in mentality are not achieved through education, it will be hard to change these unhealthy patterns because they are seen as an inherent part of the sport.…”

Authors’ Reply to Davis: “It is Time to Ban Rapid Weight Loss from Combat Sports”

“…Although not all studies reported that weight loss is associated with competitive success, none reported that weight loss is associated with less success, rendering RWL to be either beneficial or not harmful to competitive performance. Other than the physical advantages, there is evidence that RWL may also confer mental advantage [35]. The potential is, therefore, clear.…”

“…Therefore, an athlete wanting to compete against opponents of similar sizes will have no option other than to also engage in RWL procedures. This was made obvious by a combat athlete interviewed in the study by Petterson et al [35] who said "(…) if I wouldn't cut weight and everyone else does it, then I would be in trouble." This benefits those willing to take the risks and discomforts associated with RWL to the detriment of those unwilling to compromise their health by undertaking these stressful strategies;…”

The strategy differences and movement pattern between medalist and non-medalist taekwondo youth athlete

“…Taekwondo is one of the combat sports and can be described as a modern Olympic sport that required high intensity, to defeat the exponent using precise and quick kicks [1]. Among classical taekwondo competitions types (i.e.…”