Pragmatism in professional practice

Abstract

In recent years, there has been a resurgence of interest in the American philosophy of pragmatism. The paper reviews the application of pragmatisms in five selected areas of professional practice: technology, law, politics, medical and social work, and education. Each area is examined for evidence that the ideas of pragmatism have been taken up academically in the research literature. The literature is then examined for evidence that the academic work has permeated the actions of professionals. Each of the chosen practice areas is clearly dominated by pragmatic, instrumental activities. Despite this and a good deal of discussion in the academic literature, there is only limited evidence that professionals, in so far as they exhibit pragmatist behaviour, make any explicit connection with the philosophy of pragmatism. The early pragmatists argued that pragmatic behaviour arises from man's need to solve problems quickly, using his limited understanding of the situation, in order to survive and flourish: no philosophy had been required to guide such behaviour. Today, philosophy is often consulted on questions of ethical and moral dilemmas in most practice areas, but the philosophy of pragmatism may well not feature in such discussions. Experience in operational research (OR) practice is reviewed and compared with that in the five other practice areas. From the reviews, a list of the habits and orientations is synthesized, habits and orientations that could be taken to characterize pragmatism in professional practice.

Holistic Flexibility for Deploying Systems Thinking as a Cognitive Skill

“…Greater industry adoption of ST will enable practitioners working in complex situations accrue the benefits of a systemic mindset. Ormerod (2021) makes mention of philosophical pragmatism as having a long history in OR; in his words: Philosophical pragmatism has a long history in OR. Charles West Churchman (1913Churchman ( -2004 and Russell Ackoff (1919Ackoff ( -2009, both with a background in philosophy, based their approaches to OR on pragmatist thinking as taught to them by the pragmatist Edward A.…”

The logic of semiotics applied to mathematical and social interaction in operational research consulting practice: Towards a foundational view

“…Work colleagues and networks developed over time also help sustain knowledge and learning. There has been a long tradition in the fields of education and organizational learning of turning to Dewey's pragmatism for inspiration and guidance (Brandi & Elkjær, 2013; Buch & Elkjær, 2015; Ormerod, 2020b). Wenger (1998) identifies learning, meaning and identity as key concepts in the development and continued existence of communities.…”

Rebooting the systems approach by applying the thinking of Bogdanov and the pragmatists

“…Following von Bertalanffy's worldview, rather than the scientific pretensions of his general systems theory, it is natural to turn to the more applied areas of the systems tradition, most of which were influenced by his work. Ormerod (2020Ormerod ( , 2021 sees operational research consulting practice as following a pragmatic logic and usefully sets out where to look in other areas of the operational research and systems literature for evidence of a pragmatic orientation. Barton (1999) sets out some direct and less direct influences of pragmatism on applied systems thinking, paying particular attention to system dynamics.…”