“…In this context, we have reported systematic measurements of reactivity of the doped clusters against O 2 ; oxygen etching is frequently employed to examine the stability of the clusters. − When multiple-collision reaction experiments are performed, not only the reactivity but also successive elementary reaction processes can be elucidated. − We have found that the doped anionic clusters, Ag 14 Sc – , Ag 13 Ti – , and Ag 12 V – , as well as cationic clusters, Ag 16 Sc + , Ag 15 Ti + , Ag 14 V + , Ag 11 Fe + , Ag 10 Co + , and Ag 9 Ni + , exhibit a reactivity minimum in the size-dependent measurement of reaction rate coefficients along with reaction kinetics; − the low reactivity suggests that these clusters are stable due to the 18-electron shell closure including delocalized 3d electrons of the dopant atom. In contrast, Ag 9 Fe – , Ag 8 Co – , and Ag 7 Ni – , possessing an exohedral dopant geometry, were highly reactive even with 18 valence electrons, which suggests that an endohedral geometry plays a key role in 3d delocalization …”