Spent fermentation media from bioprocessing represent a significant waste stream, and interest in recycling them as part of the developing circular bioeconomy is growing. The potential to reuse yeast spent culture media (YSM) to feed secondary bacterial fermentations producing recombinant protein was investigated in this study. Elemental and amino acid compositional analysis using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and LC-MS/MS identified significant differences in the concentrations of 6 elements and 18/20 amino acids in YSM compared with rich microbiological media (LB). Restoration of levels of magnesium and sodium through addition of their salts and amino acids from tryptone supplementation led to the expression of equivalent titres of recombinant proteins by E. coli (0.275 g/L), compared to that in LB media (0.296 g/L) and BMMY media (0.294 g/L) in shake flask culture. When this supplementation strategy was employed in a bioreactor system, we observed a significant increase in recombinant protein titre using the supplemented YSM (2.29 (±0.02) g/L) over that produced using LB media (1.29 (±0.09) g/L). This study demonstrates through highly sensitive compositional analysis and identification of supplementation strategies the potential to valorise spent media from yeast fermentations that underpin industrial processes of significant scale, creating a circular approach to waste stream management.