Predicting eyes at risk for rapid glaucoma progression based on an initial visual field test using machine learning

Abstract

Objective To assess whether machine learning algorithms (MLA) can predict eyes that will undergo rapid glaucoma progression based on an initial visual field (VF) test. Design Retrospective analysis of longitudinal data. Subjects 175,786 VFs (22,925 initial VFs) from 14,217 patients who completed ≥5 reliable VFs at academic glaucoma centers were included. Methods Summary measures and reliability metrics from the initial VF and age were used to train MLA designed to predict the likelihood of rapid progression. Additionally, the neural network model was trained with point-wise threshold data in addition to summary measures, reliability metrics and age. 80% of eyes were used for a training set and 20% were used as a test set. MLA test set performance was assessed using the area under the receiver operating curve (AUC). Performance of models trained on initial VF data alone was compared to performance of models trained on data from the first two VFs. Main outcome measures Accuracy in predicting future rapid progression defined as MD worsening more than 1 dB/year. Results 1,968 eyes (8.6%) underwent rapid progression. The support vector machine model (AUC 0.72 [95% CI 0.70–0.75]) most accurately predicted rapid progression when trained on initial VF data. Artificial neural network, random forest, logistic regression and naïve Bayes classifiers produced AUC of 0.72, 0.70, 0.69, 0.68 respectively. Models trained on data from the first two VFs performed no better than top models trained on the initial VF alone. Based on the odds ratio (OR) from logistic regression and variable importance plots from the random forest model, older age (OR: 1.41 per 10 year increment [95% CI: 1.34 to 1.08]) and higher pattern standard deviation (OR: 1.31 per 5-dB increment [95% CI: 1.18 to 1.46]) were the variables in the initial VF most strongly associated with rapid progression. Conclusions MLA can be used to predict eyes at risk for rapid progression with modest accuracy based on an initial VF test. Incorporating additional clinical data to the current model may offer opportunities to predict patients most likely to rapidly progress with even greater accuracy.

Predictors of limited early response to anti-vascular endothelial growth factor therapy in neovascular age-related macular degeneration with machine learning feature importance

“…The model's AUC of 0.66 showed that the study variables contribute to LER prediction, but that other variables are involved as well [ Figure 1a ]. Previous ML studies predicting outcomes in ophthalmic diseases have achieved AUC ranging from 0.68 to 0.79,[ 10 11 21 ] while higher performance has been achieved with large datasets and/or deep learning approaches. [ 7 12 16 ] The present study is remarkable in achieving moderate performance with only a limited number of baseline features.…”

Reverse translation of artificial intelligence in glaucoma: Connecting basic science with clinical applications

“…Visual field measurement is a low-cost diagnostic tool for evaluating visual function. By using a deep neural network trained on low dimensional, baseline 2D visual field measurements, recent studies showed promising predictive power in forecasting the risk of rapid glaucomatous progression ( 12 , 13 ). On the other hand, OCT may be capable of predicting visual field progression ( 14 ).…”

Artificial intelligence and glaucoma progression

“…In a retrospective cohort, Shuldiner et al evaluated the ability of different MLCs to detect fast visual field progressors (MD reduction > 1 dB/year). 29 They included a total of 175,786 SAP exams (22,925 initial ones) from 14,217 patients who completed 5 reliable visual fields. Among the MLCs, the support vector machine model (AUC 0.72) presented the highest accuracy to predict progression.…”