Predicting Psychotic Relapse in Schizophrenia With Mobile Sensor Data: Routine Cluster Analysis

Abstract

Background Behavioral representations obtained from mobile sensing data can be helpful for the prediction of an oncoming psychotic relapse in patients with schizophrenia and the delivery of timely interventions to mitigate such relapse. Objective In this study, we aim to develop clustering models to obtain behavioral representations from continuous multimodal mobile sensing data for relapse prediction tasks. The identified clusters can represent different routine behavioral trends related to daily living of patients and atypical behavioral trends associated with impending relapse. Methods We used the mobile sensing data obtained from the CrossCheck project for our analysis. Continuous data from six different mobile sensing-based modalities (ambient light, sound, conversation, acceleration, etc) obtained from 63 patients with schizophrenia, each monitored for up to a year, were used for the clustering models and relapse prediction evaluation. Two clustering models, Gaussian mixture model (GMM) and partition around medoids (PAM), were used to obtain behavioral representations from the mobile sensing data. These models have different notions of similarity between behaviors as represented by the mobile sensing data, and thus, provide different behavioral characterizations. The features obtained from the clustering models were used to train and evaluate a personalized relapse prediction model using balanced random forest. The personalization was performed by identifying optimal features for a given patient based on a personalization subset consisting of other patients of similar age. Results The clusters identified using the GMM and PAM models were found to represent different behavioral patterns (such as clusters representing sedentary days, active days but with low communication, etc). Although GMM-based models better characterized routine behaviors by discovering dense clusters with low cluster spread, some other identified clusters had a larger cluster spread, likely indicating heterogeneous behavioral characterizations. On the other hand, PAM model-based clusters had lower variability of cluster spread, indicating more homogeneous behavioral characterization in the obtained clusters. Significant changes near the relapse periods were observed in the obtained behavioral representation features from the clustering models. The clustering model-based features, together with other features characterizing the mobile sensing data, resulted in an F2 score of 0.23 for the relapse prediction task in a leave-one-patient-out evaluation setting. The obtained F2 score was significantly higher than that of a random classification baseline with an average F2 score of 0.042. Conclusions Mobile sensing can capture behavioral trends using different sensing modalities. Clustering of the daily mobile sensing data may help discover routine and atypical behavioral trends. In this study, we used GMM-based and PAM-based cluster models to obtain behavioral trends in patients with schizophrenia. The features derived from the cluster models were found to be predictive for detecting an oncoming psychotic relapse. Such relapse prediction models can be helpful in enabling timely interventions.

Machine Learning for Multimodal Mental Health Detection: A Systematic Review of Passive Sensing Approaches

“…In conjunction with an existing finding that individuals with similar depression scores may portray behavioral differences under similar contexts [ 156 ], several researchers attempted to achieve individual personalization by training subject-specific models [ 164 , 169 , 205 , 207 ], fine-tuning subject-specific layers [ 161 ] in a global NN architecture, and deducing personalized predictions by incorporating information from other samples homogeneous to each individual based on correlation coefficients [ 156 ] or demographics [ 208 ] such as age [ 209 ].…”

On the Road to Individualizing Pharmacotherapy for Adolescents and Adults with Schizophrenia – Results from an Expert Consensus Following the Delphi Method

“… 107 , 108 For example, clustering of mobile sensor data can be used to detect routine and atypical behavioral trends associated with impending psychotic relapse in patients with schizophrenia. 109 While this is still an evolving area, and not entirely within the scope of this paper, it is not difficult to imagine that we will be able to progressively obtain better markers of complex human behaviors and related emotional and cognitive states that characterize mental health and illness states to support the individualization of mental health care. Importantly, these new developments will be integrated with shared decision making and other aspects of chronic disease management, 110 while respecting the patient’s own cultural environment.…”

E-Prevention: Advanced Support System for Monitoring and Relapse Prevention in Patients with Psychotic Disorders Analyzing Long-Term Multimodal Data from Wearables and Video Captures

“…This is especially significant in mental health monitoring, where the availability of data corresponding to relapsing states is scarce. Such unsupervised anomaly detection algorithms, such as, for instance, autoencoder neural networks, have been developed and applied on audio signals [ 86 , 87 ] and medical images [ 88 ], as well as data collected from various passive sensors [ 48 , 89 , 90 , 91 ].…”