Prediction of Preoperative Anxiety in Children: Who Is Most Accurate?

Abstract

Background In this investigation, we sought to assess the ability of pediatric attending anesthesiologists, resident anesthesiologists and mothers to predict anxiety during induction of anesthesia in 2 to 16-year-old children (n=125). Methods Anesthesiologists and mothers provided predictions using a visual analog scale and children's anxiety was assessed using a valid behavior observation tool the Modified Yale Preoperative Anxiety Scale (mYPAS). All mothers were present during anesthetic induction and no child received sedative premedication. Correlational analyses were conducted. Results A total of 125 children aged 2 to 16 years, their mothers, and their attending pediatric anesthesiologists and resident anesthesiologists were studied. Correlational analyses revealed significant associations between attending predictions and child anxiety at induction (rs= 0.38, p<0.001). Resident anesthesiologist and mother predictions were not significantly related to children's anxiety during induction (rs = 0.01 and 0.001, respectively). In terms of accuracy of prediction, 47.2% of predictions made by attending anesthesiologists were within one standard deviation of the observed anxiety exhibited by the child, and 70.4% of predictions were within 2 standard deviations. Conclusions We conclude that attending anesthesiologists who practice in pediatric settings are better than mothers in predicting the anxiety of children during induction of anesthesia. While this finding has significant clinical implications, it is unclear if it can be extended to attending anesthesiologists whose practice is not mostly pediatric anesthesia.

An evaluation of preoperative anxiety in Spanish‐speaking and Latino children in the United States

“…Children who were younger and rated as less sociable had higher levels of preoperative anxiety. This finding agrees with past research as children of younger age (1‐6 years) often do not have the coping abilities to handle stressful situations . Furthermore, in past studies it has been found that less sociable children have higher anxiety as they are often uncomfortable in new social situations such as awaiting surgery in the hospital …”

Reduction of Preoperative Anxiety in Pediatric Surgery Patients Using Age-Appropriate Teaching Interventions

“…Maternal anxiety was evaluated on leaving the OR using the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory tool. 8 MacLaren et al 8 conducted correlational analyses to determine the association between attending anesthesiologist predictions of child anxiety and actual child anxiety at induction of anesthesia and revealed moderate-to-good predictability (P , .001). Anesthesiologists considered the child's behavior in holding, the age of the child, and temperament when assessing anxiety.…”

“…This suggests that preoperative teaching strategies must not only be age appropriate, but should take into consideration the child's social adaptability, cognitive ability, and temperament. 8 Routine methods of decreasing preoperative anxiety in children include the use of pharmacological therapies and presence of parents during induction. The routine use of preoperative sedatives to reduce anxiety in pediatric patients may result in increased costs, necessitate additional nursing staff, and increase the need for appropriately equipped bed space in the preoperative holding area.…”

Reducing Anxiety in the Pediatric Emergency Department: A Comparative Trial

“…SA may have lasting effects on how patients use the health care system or comply with treatment recommendations [2]. However, SA in children can be difficult to detect and treat [3,4]. For this reason, the American Academy of Pediatrics endorses that health care professionals have a responsibility to address anxiety and create favorable environmental conditions for pediatric patients in the PED setting [5].…”