“…Thus, active electrocatalysts based on earth-abundant elements, such as transition metal compounds, have been extensively studied to replace noble metals 11,12 . Transition metal oxides 13,14 , hydroxides 15,16 , carbide 17 , nitride 18 , phosphide 19 , and sulfides 20–22 have been studied as OER electrocatalysts under alkaline conditions, and transition metal sulfides 20–22 , phosphides 6,7 , carbonitride 23 , and selenides 24 have been studied as HER electrocatalysts under acidic conditions. In regard to OER and HER performance, the effects of activation and optimization of electrocatalysts have recently been reported 17,18,23 .…”