Predictive Models for Freshwater Biological Assessment: Statistical Approaches, Biological Elements and the Iberian Peninsula Experience: A Review

Abstract

In the last three decades, predictive models have been developed and applied worldwide for freshwater bioassessment. They consist of statistical tools that follow the concept of the Reference Condition Approach. Composed of several sequential steps, these assessment tools assess the deviation of given site assemblages from the expected biological condition in the absence of human disturbance. The most common approaches (RIVPACS/AUSRIVAS and BEAST) are based on a posteriori classifications that use the biological composition of a community to classify reference sites in groups, and afterwards to establish which environmental features best discriminate the biological groups obtained. Here, we review the predictive modeling procedures used in freshwaters bioassessment (RIVPACS/AUSRIVAS, BEAST, ANNA, Artificial Neural Networks, Bayesian Belief Networks and others) as well as the biological elements to which they have been applied.We also review the Spanish and Portuguese experiences in the development and application of predictive models, with particular attention to regional environmental conditions, the different modeling approaches, and the available implementation tools. Moreover, and considering the natural continuity within the Iberian Peninsula (which include several transnational rivers), we discuss the possibilities of the development of common predictive models across the region, considering all factors that may influence their performance, such as the target scale used to develop the models (regional or peninsular); common reference criteria; sampling and sorting procedures; the taxonomic resolution used in the models; the temporal variability (mainly in the Iberian Mediterranean region); and the biological elements to consider. We concluded that there are good technical conditions for the implementations of a common predictive approach throughout the Iberian Peninsula, which should allow a global biological assessment of streams with different biological elements and seasons that could be used by water managers in the context of the Water Framework Directive.

Diversity measures in macroinvertebrate and zooplankton communities related to the trophic status of subtropical reservoirs: Contradictory or complementary responses?

“…These organisms are also sensitive to physical and chemical changes in different ecosystems and their responses to these changes are detectable and measurable (Barbour et al, 1996;Moreno and Callisto, 2006). Currently, the macroinvertebrate community has also been used to design predictive ecological tools, as has often occurred in European and U.S countries (Bonada et al, 2006;Feio and Poquet, 2011;Berthon et al, 2011;Smith et al, 1999;Demars et al, 2012). In Brazil, some studies have been performed on rivers (Baptista et al, 2007;Oliveira et al, 2011) and reservoirs (Molozzi et al, 2012(Molozzi et al, , 2013.…”

Ecological Modelling Applied to Entomology

“…Usually, the predictive modelling step is performed with general linear models -from multivariate discriminant function analysis to logistic regressions. Predictive models based upon Artificial Intelligence, such as Artificial Neural Networks or Bayesian Belief Networks, have also been proposed (Feio and Poquet 2011). Among the indices calculated in step (5), the O/E ratio of observed to expected taxon richness is one of the most used.…”

A predictive index based on environmental filters for the bioassessment of river basins without reference areas in Atlantic Forest biome, Brazil

“…Biological assessments are generally based on measurements of attributes of biological assemblages, which are often characterized and expressed as indices. Different types of indices have been developed (Hawkins et al 2010, Feio & Poquet 2011, Herman & Nejadhashemi 2015, but most of these methods share the need to use a benchmark (i.e. a reference condition), from which the measured biological condition will be compared.…”