Systematic reviewTranscatheter closure is a widespread technique used to treat secundum atrial septal defects (ASDs). When compared to surgery, it provides a less invasive approach with quicker recovery and reduced physical and psychological impact (1-4).The first case was performed in 1976 by King and Mills (5). However, the percutaneous ASD closure fully entered the clinical arena with the introduction of Amplatzer septal occluder devices (ASO) (6). Since then, many other devices have been developed and used, such as the Gore Cardioform septal occluder (GSO), the Figulla Flexible Occlutech device, the Cardioseal/Starflex and the bio absorbable devices Biostar or Biotrek (7,8).Nowadays, almost 85-90% of all secundum ASD can be closed by using a transcatheter approach (9,10). However, several limitations may have a significant impact on the feasibility and success of percutaneous ASD closure (11,12).Limitations can be grouped as follows: (I) anatomical limitations; (II) device-related limitations; (III) associated defects and natural history associated issues; (IV) physiological limitations; (V) complications.
Anatomical limitationsA common underlying structure apply to all available devices: they are made of two disks and a connecting segment that keeps them together across the ASD. Two different engineering concepts have been developed, so that occluder devices can be classified as self-centering and nonself-centering ones. The Amplatzer and the Amplatzer-like devices, in which a central connecting waist fills the defect improving stability and occlusion, belong to the former, while devices such as GSO, where the connecting segment is linear, belong to the latter. All the currently available devices need to have surrounding "walls" supporting their stability. In particular, the disks of non-self-centering ones should be 1.8-2 times the diameter of the defect in order to have complete defect closure and avoid mal position or embolization (8).Main anatomical limitations to percutaneous ASD closure may be insufficient surrounding rims, multiple defects and excessively bulging atrial septal aneurisms (ASA).Typical of ostium primum ASD and sinus venosus-type defects, deficiency of surrounding rims can affect ostium