“…The catalytic activity of Cu-Co 9 S 8 -6h is greatly improved, only need 260 mV overpotential to drive 50 mA cm –2 , which is 60, 130, 140, 180, and 200 mV lower than those of Co 9 S 8 -6h (320 mV), Cu-Co 9 S 8 -8h (390 mV), Cu-Co 9 S 8 -4h (400 mV), Cu-Co-MOF/NF (440 mV), and Cu-Co(CO 3 ) (OH)/NF (460 mV), respectively (Figure d). Compared with the previously reported noble-free metal electrode, the Cu-Co 9 S 8 -6h catalyst showed excellent electrochemical activity than that of the reported materials, for example, Cu 3 P/CF (∼412 mV), carbonate-Co(OH) 2 /NF (∼337 mV), MnCo 2 S 4 NA/TM (∼325 mV), NiFe-LDH@NiFe-Bi/CC (∼294 mV), Al-CoP/NF (∼280 mV), and RuO 2 (330 mV) (Figure S10). The dynamics of catalytic materials are reflected by the Tafel slope (Figure b), the Cu-Co 9 S 8 -6h has a lower Tafel slope (76.7 mV/dec) than those of Cu-Co 9 S 8 -8h (79.3 mV/dec), Cu-Co 9 S 8 -4h (106.4 mV/dec), Cu-Co-MOF/NF (141.9 mV/dec), and Cu-Co(CO 3 )(OH)/NF (284.7 mV/dec) (Figure b).…”