Presbyterian Moral Economy: The Covenanting Tradition and Popular Protest in Lowland Scotland, 1707–c.1746

Abstract

This paper explores the religious dimension to popular protest in the early eighteenth century, highlighting in particular the continued influence of what has been called the Covenanting tradition – the defence of Presbyterian church government, popular sovereignty and the resistance of Anglican imperialism – in southwest and west central Scotland. Religiously inspired ideas of equality and economic equity in God's world, combined with the desire to resist the encroachment of Anglican hierarchy, drove ordinary Presbyterians to rebel. There is evidence to suggest that the reaction of some protesters to socio-economic conditions was coloured by their theological worldview. The phenomenon at work in southwest Scotland might best be described as ‘Presbyterian moral economy’. The paper suggests that lowland Presbyterian culture coloured popular protest to a degree not hitherto recognised. Presbyterian moral economy was a robust and continuous – but unduly neglected – strand in the history of Scottish radicalism.

The Equivalent Societies of Edinburgh and London, the Formation of the Royal Bank of Scotland, and the Nature of the Scottish Financial Revolution

“…130 Perhaps the most significant rioting was in Shawfield, Glasgow, during which the house of Daniel Campbell, a member of Parliament for the city, was ransacked after rumors abounded that Campbell had supported the tax; eight civilians were killed by soldiers in the process. 131 During this turbulent period, the specter of Jacobitism continued to raise its head. While there is little to link the igniting of events to the cause-indeed we should note Whatley's word of caution that not every occasion of unrest in the early eighteenth century was the result of Jacobitism-there was a fear that Jacobites may take the opportunity to undermine the British government.…”

The Covenanter sensibility across the long Atlantic World

“…This is what Valerie Wallace has dubbed in a Scottish context the 'Presbyterian moral economy'. 23 Being part of this heroic tradition of resistance was empowering to the laity, and their leaders were as much representatives of that empowerment as the providers of it. In cell groups like religious societies, family devotionals and other associations, they told and retold the stories of the Covenanter past, sure that these mythologies held very real meaning for their own lives.…”