Growth and metabolic activity of non-adapted microorganisms can be hindered by mild hydrostatic pressure (mHP). The detrimental outcomes of mHP might be alleviated through counteracting effects and stress responses already implemented for salinity and thermal tolerance. Together, these environmental parameters might allow steering between growth and product formation in anaerobic bioprocesses. In this work, we studied the effects of mHP, namely 5 and 8 MPa, of two anaerobic halotolerant inocula: one from coastal marine sediment enriched at 10, 20 and 28°C and other from a mesophilic reactor treating petrochemical wastewater at 37°C. At the cell level, we investigated the effect on growth and energy metabolism, and at the community level, we studied changes in structure and taxonomic diversity. Bioenergetics calculations pointed out that the concomitant action of mHP and temperature trigger energy management strategies at the cell level. Through them, decreased energy levels could be re-allocated to satisfy increased maintenance at the expense of growth, especially at higher temperatures. The mHP had an unbalancing impact on the growth kinetics of different microbial groups and their associated biochemical reactions, which is reflected in the accumulation of volatile fatty acids at the lower temperatures, i.e., <20°C. At the community scale, an overall decrease in absolute abundance was observed as a result of increased mHP, the establishment of predominant groups and the disappearance of the least adapted ones. Overall, understanding of the effects of stress conditions, such as pressure, salinity and abnormal temperature levels, at different biological levels of organization can help to redesign bioprocesses and steer among targets as productivity and yield.