Prevalence and Framing of Health Disparities in Local Print News: Implications for Multilevel Interventions to Address Cancer Inequalities

Abstract

Background Americans remain under-informed about cancer and other health disparities and the social determinants of health (SDH). The news media may be contributing to this knowledge deficit, whether by discussing these issues narrowly or ignoring them altogether. Because local media are particularly important in influencing public opinion and support for public policies, this study examines the prevalence and framing of disparities/SDH in local mainstream and ethnic print news. Methods We conducted a multi-method content analysis of local mainstream (English-language) and ethnic (Spanish-language) print news in two lower-income cities in New England with substantial racial/ethnic minority populations. After establishing inter-coder reliability (kappa=0.63–0.88), coders reviewed the primary English- and Spanish-language newspaper in each city, identifying both disparities and non-disparities health stories published between February 2010 and January 2011. Results Local print news coverage of cancer and other health disparities was rare. Of 650 health stories published across four newspapers during the one-year study period, only 21 (3.2%) discussed disparities/SDH. Although some stories identified causes of and solutions for disparities, these were often framed in individual (e.g., poor dietary habits) rather than social contextual terms (e.g., lack of food availability/affordability). Cancer and other health stories routinely missed opportunities to discuss disparities/SDH. Conclusion Local mainstream and ethnic media may be ideal targets for multilevel interventions designed to address cancer and other health inequalities. Impact By increasing media attention to and framing of health disparities, we may observe important downstream effects on public opinion and support for structural solutions to disparities, particularly at the local level.

Television News Coverage of Public Health Issues and Implications for Public Health Policy and Practice

“…Other work has explored the implications of reporting on health disparities in news (9). While local news outlets rarely mention health disparities (88), the way that the news frames these issues is consequential. News stories emphasize behavioral explanations for health disparities at the expense of broader social or economic explanations (65), and stories that explicitly compare racial/ethnic groups ("social comparison framing") can lead to (a) underestimates of disease risk among the less at-risk group ( 9) and (b) lower intentions to engage in relevant screening tests among the disadvantaged group (90).…”

Rural Women’s Perceptions About Cancer Disparities and Contributing Factors: a Call to Communication

“…These results are somewhat surprising. Past research in a non-rural setting suggested that local news coverage of cancer disparities was relatively limited [47] Understanding the source of health disparity information among rural respondents is an important next step, especially in terms of ensuring accurate and up-to-date information is communicated to targeted populations in the future. Greater awareness may be a result of personal experiences, as respondents mostly emphasized the burden of cancer for their own communities and social networks.…”

Media Reporting on Air Pollution: Health Risk and Precautionary Measures in National and Regional Newspapers

“…Media influences which issues the public are exposed to and thereby sets the public agenda [ 18 ]. Agenda-setting research has furthermore shown that news coverage plays a role in shaping public opinion and the local policy agenda, and that this role is more prominent for local-level news [ 19 ].…”