A fundamental problem for disease treatment is that while antibiotics are a powerful counter to bacteria, they are ineffective against viruses. To ensure a given individual receives optimal treatment given their disease state and to reduce over-prescription of antibiotics leading to antimicrobial resistance, the host response can be measured to distinguish between the two states. To establish a predictive biomarker panel of disease state we conducted a meta-analysis of human blood infection studies using Machine Learning (ML). We focused on publicly available gene expression data from two widely used platforms, Affymetrix and Illumina microarrays, and integrated over 2000 samples for each platform to develop optimal gene panels. On average our models predicted 80% of bacterial and 85% viral samples correctly by class of infection type. For our best performing model, identified with an evolutionary algorithm, 93% of bacterial and 89% of viral samples were classified correctly. To enable comparison between the two differing microarray platforms, we reverse engineered the underlying molecular regulatory network and overlay the identified models. This revealed that although the exact gene-level overlap between models generated from the two technologies was relatively low, both models contained genes in the same areas of the network, indicating that the same functional changes in host biology were being detected, providing further confidence in the robustness of our models. Specifically, this convergence was to pathways including the Type I interferon Signalling Pathway, Chemotaxis, Apoptotic Processes, and Inflammatory / Innate Response. Amongst and related to these pathways we found three genes, IFI27, LY6E, and CD177, particularly prevalent throughout our analysis.