Price and subsidy under uncertainty: Real-option approach to optimal investment decisions on energy storage with solar PV

Abstract

Renewable generation sources still have not achieved economic validity in many countries including Korea, and require subsidies to support the transition to a low-carbon economy. An initial Feed-In Tariff (FIT) was adopted to support the deployment of renewable energy in Korea until 2011 and then was switched to the Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) to implement more market-oriented mechanisms. However, high volatilities in electricity prices and subsidies under the RPS scheme have weakened investment incentives. In this study we estimate how the multiple price volatilities under the RPS scheme affect the optimal investment decisions of energy storage projects, whose importance is increasing rapidly because they can mitigate the variability and uncertainty of solar and wind generation in the power system. We applied mathematical analysis based on real-option methods to estimate the optimal trigger price for investment in energy-storage projects with and without multiple price volatilities. We found that the optimal trigger price of subsidy called the Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) under multiple price volatilities is 10.5% higher than that under no price volatilities. If the volatility of the REC price gets doubled, the project requires a 26.6% higher optimal investment price to justify the investment against the increased risk. In the end, we propose an auction scheme that has the advantage of both RPS and FIT in order to minimize the financial burden of the subsidy program by eliminating subsidy volatility and find the minimum willingness-to-accept price for investors.

Will a Geopolitical Conflict Accelerate Energy Transition in Oil-Importing Countries? A Case Study of the Philippines from a Real Options Perspective

“…As a consequence, a project planner tends to increase the uncertainty of expected returns in energy transition and then implement the project or back out, depending on changes in investment conditions. On the contrary, higher uncertainty increases the value of the real option, hence, prolonging the decision to implement the investment [68][69][70].…”

Green Certificates Research: Bibliometric Assessment of Current State and Future Directions

“…Starting with the foundational role of policy incentives, Peng et al [180] and Zhang et al [54] explore how tradable green certificates shape investment decisions in wind power and renewable energy portfolios. Wang et al [181] and Qu and Jeon [182] further examine the transition to competitive electricity markets, emphasizing the stabilizing influence of renewable energy certificates in the face of subsidy and price volatilities. Safarzadeh et al [183] argue for the efficacy of mandatory fines over subsidies in guiding traditional energy suppliers toward renewable alternatives.…”

Economic and Regulatory Uncertainty in Renewable Energy System Design: A Review

“…Therefore, because of its convenience, GBM is ubiquitous in the analyzed literature. Besides electricity prices, coal prices [120], FiT degression [82], LCOE [85], demand growth [83], green certificate prices [27,102], and renewable output [13] have been modeled using GBM.…”