Primary Care Provider Perceptions of Colorectal Cancer Screening Barriers: Implications for Designing Quality Improvement Interventions

Abstract

Aims. Colorectal cancer (CRC) screening is underutilized. Increasing CRC screening rates requires interventions targeting multiple barriers at each level of the healthcare organization (patient, provider, and system). We examined groups of primary care providers (PCPs) based on perceptions of screening barriers and the relationship to CRC screening rates to inform approaches for conducting barrier assessments prior to designing and implementing quality improvement interventions. Methods. We conducted a retrospective cohort study linking EHR and survey data. PCPs with complete survey responses for questions addressing CRC screening barriers were included (N = 166 PCPs; 39,430 patients eligible for CRC screening). Cluster analysis identified groups of PCPs. Multivariate logistic regression estimated odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals for predictors of membership in one of the PCP groups. Results. We found two distinct groups: (1) PCPs identifying multiple barriers to CRC screening at patient, provider, and system levels (N = 75) and (2) PCPs identifying no major barriers to screening (N = 91). PCPs in the top half of CRC screening performance were more likely to identify multiple barriers than the bottom performers (OR, 4.14; 95% CI, 2.43–7.08). Conclusions. High-performing PCPs can more effectively identify CRC screening barriers. Targeting high-performers when conducting a barrier assessment is a novel approach to assist in designing quality improvement interventions for CRC screening.

Geospatial analysis of the influence of family doctor on colorectal cancer screening adherence

“…The FDs perception of barriers to CRC screening participation results in significantly different FDs performances, as reported by Weiss et al [35]. Barrier identification and perception may relate to active FD involvement in the screening campaign.…”

Building the learning health system: Describing an organizational infrastructure to support continuous learning

“…Interventions to achieve strategic goals in quality of care and patient experience in a relatively short period of time were purposefully designed to impact the various levels of the health system in critical domains without attempting to identify the relative impact of each intervention. Individual organizations seeking to design system change can use this framework to build from their strengths and identify specific areas that need growth . The selection of specific interventions will need to vary according to local context and priorities.…”

Perceived susceptibility to developing cancer and screening for colorectal and prostate cancer: A longitudinal analysis of Alberta’s Tomorrow Project

“…8 However, despite the existence of well-established screening guidelines and the widely communicated benefits of screening, screening remains underutilized in many jurisdictions. 9 The Health Belief Model (HBM) is a cognitive model that comprises several core constructs, which are often examined additively to assess the likelihood of an individual performing a given behaviour. [10][11][12] Further, the HBM suggests one's personal beliefs regarding a disease will influence health behaviours such as screening.…”

“…8 However, despite the existence of well-established screening guidelines and the widely communicated benefits of screening, screening remains underutilized in many jurisdictions. 9…”