Malignancies arising from retrovirally transduced hematopoietic stem cells have been reported in animal models and human gene therapy trials. Whether mature lymphocytes are susceptible to insertional mutagenesis is unknown. We have characterized a primary human CD8 ؉ Tcell clone, which exhibited logarithmic ex vivo growth in the absence of exogenous cytokine support for more than 1 year after transduction with a murine leukemia virus-based vector encoding the T-cell growth factor IL-15. Phenotypically, the clone was CD28 ؊ , CD45RA ؊ , CD45RO ؉ , and CD62L ؊ , a profile consistent with effector memory T lymphocytes. After gene transfer with tumor-antigenspecific T-cell receptors, the clone secreted IFN-␥ upon encountering tumor targets, providing further evidence that they derived from mature lymphocytes.
IntroductionHuman gene therapy strategies using replication-incompetent retroviral vectors were implemented cautiously because of many concerns, including the potential for adverse events resulting from vector insertions in the human genome. 1 Theoretical concerns about insertional mutagenesis became reality with the report that 3 of 11 patients with severe combined immunodeficiency-X1 (SCID-X1) developed T-cell leukemia after treatment with hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) engineered with the common ␥-chain cytokine receptor gene. These leukemias resulted from integration events which activated the LMO2 proto-oncogene. 2 Nevertheless, after more than 17 years of clinical gene therapy trials this remains the only report of overt cancer development resulting from genemodified cell therapy. Our understanding of the pathogenesis of human malignancy resulting from insertional mutagenesis remains limited to this specific clinical scenario.Several observations from the SCID-X1 gene therapy trial fall in line with general principles established through animal models and other human clinical trials investigating retroviral gene transfer. The well-characterized murine leukemia virus (MLV)-based gene transfer vectors integrate preferentially in the vicinity of cellular promoters, 3,4 potentially increasing the probability of activating or inactivating vector insertions which may dysregulate gene expression. 5,6 The target cells most at risk of insertional mutagenesis are believed to be primitive progenitor cells. 7 Potentially, therapeutic transgenes may have leukemogenic properties in the appropriate setting. 6 The interactions between retroviral gene transfer vectors and hematopoietic cells are being investigated intensely.In this report, we have characterized a primary human T-cell clone, which exhibited continuous growth after transduction with an MLV-based retroviral vector encoding the T-cell growth factor, IL-15. This was an unexpected and intriguing finding for several reasons. First, human cells are inherently difficult to immortalize, and the process of transformation in human cells is believed to be considerably more complex than that of experimental animals. Second, the cells that were transduced consisted of...