Middle ear meningiomas (MEMs) are rare tumors that can present with nonspecific symptoms, posing challenges in diagnosis and management. This case report focuses on a middle-aged female patient who was misdiagnosed with secretory otitis media for 5 years. However, further evaluation through computed tomography imaging and subsequent pathologic biopsy revealed the presence of a MEM. The patient underwent surgical and gamma knife resection of the tumor and follow-up examination after 1 year showed no signs of recurrence. This case report highlights the importance of considering meningiomas in the differential diagnosis of middle ear pathologies and the need for careful preoperative planning for optimal outcomes. Overall, this case demonstrates that correct diagnosis and appropriate treatment can lead to successful management of MEMs.