Primary palliative care for older people in three European countries: a mortality follow-back quality study

Abstract

background Many older people with serious chronic illnesses experience complex health problems for which palliative care is indicated. We aimed to examine the quality of primary palliative care for people aged 65-84 years and those 85 years and older who died non-suddenly in three European countries. Methods This is a nationwide representative mortality follow-back study. General practitioners (GPs) belonging to epidemiological surveillance networks in Belgium (BE), Italy (IT) and Spain (ES) (2013-2015) registered weekly all deaths in their practices. We included deaths of people aged 65 and excluded sudden deaths judged by GPs. We applied a validated set of quality indicators. results GPs registered 3496 deaths, of which 2329 were non-sudden (1126 aged 65-84, 1203 aged 85+). GPs in BE (reference category) reported higher scores than IT across almost all indicators. Differences with ES were not consistent. The score in BE particularly differed from IT on GP-patient communication (aged 65-84: 61% in BE vs 20% in IT (OR=0.12, 95% CI 0.07 to 0.20) aged 85+: 47% in BE vs 9% in IT (OR=0.09, 95% CI 0.05 to 0.16)). Between BE and ES, we identified a large difference in involvement of palliative care services (aged 65-84: 62% in BE vs 89% in ES (OR=4.81, 95% CI 2.41 to 9.61) aged 85+: 61% in BE vs 77% in ES (OR=3.1, 95% CI 1.71 to 5.53)). conclusions Considerable country differences were identified in the quality of primary palliative care for older people. The data suggest room for improvement across all countries, particularly regarding pain measurement, GP-patient communication and multidisciplinary meetings. copyright.on July 11, 2020 by guest. Protected by

Primary care service use by end-of-life cancer patients: a nationwide population-based cohort study in the United Kingdom

“…However, although there is limited data on the service use of primary care by patients towards the end of life, existing studies indicate that there are considerable cross-country variations in both the quality and intensity of care, as well as room for improvement [12][13][14][15]. This identifies a need for more country-specific data on the use of primary care services by end of life cancer patients as an essential step to understanding and identifying gaps in service provision.…”

An online international comparison of palliative care identification in primary care using the Surprise Question

“…Differences and inconsistencies in the provision of palliative care have been observed amongst European countries. 27,28 A European monitoring study showed that GPs had a proactive role in the delivery of primary palliative care in the Netherlands, whereas discussions regarding incurability of illness and life expectation took place significantly less often in Spain and Italy compared to Flanders and the Netherlands. 27 The identification of, and response to, training needs of GPs and the palliative care needs of patients needs to be adapted to their respective cultural, social, healthcare and spiritual contexts.…”

Inclusion of palliative care in health care policy for older people: A directed documentary analysis in 13 of the most rapidly ageing countries worldwide

“…One concern is that without appropriate policy support, the available services may not be sufficiently accessible to older people. Continuous epidemiological monitoring of individual-level palliative care use 5,32 should follow any policy adjustments to evaluate whether they improve accessibility of services.…”