Basidiomycota represent a diverse source of natural products, particularly the sesquiterpenoids. Recently, the genome sequencing, mining, and subsequent discovery of a suite of sesquiterpene synthases was described in Omphalotus olearius. A predictive framework was developed to facilitate the discovery of sesquiterpene synthases in Basidiomycota. Phylogenetic analyses indicated a conservation of both sequence and initial cyclization mechanisms used. Here, the first robust application of this predictive framework is reported. It is used to pursue and selectively identify sesquiterpene synthases that follow a 1,6-, 1,10-, and 1,11-cyclization mechanism in the crust fungus Stereum hirsutum. The successful identification and characterization of a 1,6- and a 1,10-cyclizing sesquiterpene synthase, as well as three 1,11-cyclizing Δ-6 protoilludene synthases, is described. This study verifies the accuracy and utility of the predictive framework as a roadmap for the discovery of specific sesquiterpene synthases from Basidiomycota, representing an important step forward in natural product discovery.