“…The claim of post-natal mammalian oogenesis polarised the scientific community, with many studies supporting the presence of OSCs (Bukovsky et al 2005, Johnson et al 2005a, Virant-Klun et al 2008, Niikura et al 2009, Zou et al 2009, Pacchiarotti et al 2010, Parte et al 2011, Zhang et al 2011, White et al 2012, Zhou et al 2014, whereas many others believed the data had been misinterpreted refuting the finding of OSCs (Bristol-Gould et al 2006, Liu et al 2007, Byskov et al 2011, Kerr et al 2012, Zhang et al 2012, Lei and Spradling 2013, Yuan et al 2013 and required further evidence before believing the existence of OSCs and the idea that this work could be extended to other mammals, including humans (Telfer 2004). However, it is questionable whether studies using alternate species can be used to refute Tilly's claims in mice.…”