Productive Uncertainty: The Pedagogical Benefits of Co‐Creating Research in the Design Studio

Abstract

Balancing the competing demands of research and teaching has long been lamented by academics. The challenges associated with Covid‐19 will make this increasingly difficult. An integrated approach to research and teaching, where students are directly engaged in the production of research, may provide a useful strategy to support ongoing research within the design disciplines whilst befitting student learning. The production of original research requires a willingness to engage in – and manage –uncertainty. Contemporary higher education acknowledges that global challenges are increasing in complexity and, thus, students require opportunities to learn to productively manage this complexity. Utilising teacher observations and student feedback, this article reflects critically on a studio model, iteratively refined over two semesters, with the deliberate intent of exacerbating the complexity already present within studio pedagogy for the production of new knowledge. It outlines a set of strategies for making manageable this uncertainty for students to ensure it is beneficial for their learning. It also identifies a number of challenges educators can face when assuming a duel role as teacher and research partner; and provides advice for negotiating these challenges.

Navigating student uncertainty for productive struggle: Establishing the importance for and distinguishing types, sources, and desirability of scientific uncertainties

“…Not all uncertainties are desirable all the time. Previous research has theorized distinctions between desirable and undesirable uncertainty in classrooms using different language (e.g., desirable and undesirable difficulties; Bjork & Bjork, 2011; productive and unproductive uncertainty, McLaughlan et al, 2021; good and bad uncertainty, Beghetto, 2017). In the current position paper, Weaver's (1949) concepts of “desirable uncertainty” and “undesirable uncertainty” are adapted to differentiate between resources and opportunities to improve students' understanding from noise, irrelevance, and inappropriate information transmission.…”

Exploration of Music Teaching Reform Program in Colleges and Universities Oriented on the Development of Corporate Culture Industry

“…The results indicated that both the 5E teaching model and previous learning experiences contributed to students' conceptual learning in mechanics. Using instructor observations and student feedback, the literature [10] critically reflects on a studio model that was iteratively refined over the course of two semesters with the intent to intentionally exacerbate the complexity already present in the pedagogy to generate new knowledge. A set of strategies were outlined to enable students to manage this uncertainty to ensure that this was beneficial to student learning.…”

The application of an all-media perspective-oriented teaching in the environmental art and design program

“…Innovating the teaching and training system and training standards of the environmental art design profession can realize the cross-fertilization of the discipline of environmental art design profession with the scientific and technological revolution and industrial change, and the cross-fertilization of the professional curriculum with multidisciplinary knowledge [4][5][6][7]. Oriented by the all-media perspective, which aligns with the ability cultivation requirements of the environmental art design profession, it can give full play to the teaching advantages of project-based teaching and make teaching the environmental art design professional courses more targeted [8][9].…”