Professional Work and Professional Careers in Manchester's Business and Financial Sector

Abstract

This paper examines professional work and professional careers and the extent to which professionals face change, uncertainty and risk in their careers. The key issue is whether the power and privilege of the professions is being undermined. It draws on research from Manchester's business and financial sector including accountancy, law, actuarial work and corporate finance. Interviews with senior partners and managers in a range of organisations indicate that important changes in the professions are taking place including diversification, inter-professional competition, organisational change and specialisation. There has also been a change in relationships with clients and an intensification of work. Interviews with junior professionals show that job mobility is high in the early career although most envisaged staying with one organisation for the majority of their careers. Hours of work were long but not necessarily seen as onerous. They were well remunerated in commanding high salaries at a relatively young age with the prospect of greatly enhanced rewards in the future. Few had experiences of redundancy and none of unemployment although the consensus of opinion was that the professions are no longer a job for life. Perceptions of insecurity were greater than experiences of it. It is argued that the privilege and power of the professions can only be understood in the context of the organisations in which they are employed and the political economy in which those organisations operate. Increased economic competitiveness has led to changes in professional work but professionals continue to enjoy advantaged careers in the labour market.

Mobility, Flexible Lifestyles and Cosmopolitanism: EU Postgraduates in Manchester

“…Fostering a multifaceted service sector formed a central plank. However, while businesses in key areas of the symbolic knowledge economy such as health, higher education, IT, finance, insurance, banking and law have expanded markedly*for example by 1996 there were 50 accountancy firms in the city (Devine et al 2000: 532)*most employment growth has been in 'low-waged private services' (Peck and Ward 2002: 12). Consequently, despite the city's reconstruction, some commentators see the existence of 'two Manchesters' (Manchester Child Poverty Action Group 2001), with continuing deprivation among much of the population.…”

Identity on the line: constructing professional identity in a HR call centre

“…Such normative definitions seem out of place in a more dynamic world of work, in which professions have to maintain their position 'in the face of pressures from consumers, co-producers and wider regulatory agencies' (Collins et al, 2009, p253). Devine et al (2000) are amongst those identifying 'diversification, interprofessional competition, [and] organisational change' (p251), along with the commodification of knowledge (Covaleski et al, 2003) and an increasingly broad interpretation of 'professionalism' (Fournier, 2001), as challenges to previous conceptions of 'the professional' at work. In sum, the 'lexical minefield' of defining professional work (Collins et al, 2009, p253) has prompted increasing interest in its specific, situated meanings.…”

The Future of Regional Cities in the Information Age: The Impact of Information Technology on Manchester’s Financial and Business Services Sector

“…See, for example, Murphy's (1998) account of the niche in international corporate and financial transactions occupied by Dublin's financial services centre. 3 The wider changes in the professionals' working lives are described in Devine et al (2000). 4 Boden and Molotch (1994) go so far as to suggest that, because 'co-present interaction' is necessary for sociality, there is a 'compulsion to proximity' that is not eroded by the availability of computer-mediated channels of communication.…”