We read with interest the study of Matsumoto et al., which concluded that the evaluation of platelet count (COP) and neutrophil-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) together is an objective predictive factor for the development of pharyngocutaneous fistula (PCF) in patients undergoing total laryngectomy. 1 However, we would like to present our criticisms about the methodology and concerns about the study's conclusion.An increase in neutrophil and platelet count and a decrease in lymphocyte count is a physiological response of the innate immune system in any inflammatory condition. Therefore, NLR and COP values represent the severity of inflammation and the immune system's capacity. 2 However, the counts of white blood cells and COP-NLR ratios can be affected by age, sex, race, body mass index, diet, level of disease, time from symptom onset, and even the mean sea level. 3 And also, many factors such as malignancy, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, metabolic syndrome, acute coronary syndromes, abnormal thyroid function tests, kidney or liver dysfunction, systemic infection, and drug use may affect hematological parameters. Therefore, an expected average value or range for NLR is needed before a definitive conclusion can be reached regarding the predictive power of NLR. However, unlike cancers of other body regions, there is no standard or generally accepted threshold value for NLR in the case of head and neck cancer. 4 As a matter of fact, the authors stated that they set the cut-off value of NLR to 3.95, but they did not explain how they obtained it.In clinical practice, different hematology analyzers use different reference ranges, and different results can be obtained even for the same blood sample. 3 The authors did not provide information on the diversity of hematology analyzers and the reference range of white blood cells, although patients from four hospitals were included in the study.Finally, the study population comprises a heterogeneous group of patients who underwent laryngectomy diagnosed with laryngeal cancer, and experienced dysphagia due to neuromuscular disease without a diagnosis of malignancy. However, patients with malignancy and those using medications such as chemotherapy and glucocorticoids should be evaluated as a separate group or excluded from the study. Because malignancy status and drugs used in the treatment of malignancy affect blood parameters and COP-NLR ratios and cause a significant selection bias in the study results. 5 In consequence, the predictive value of the COP-NLR ratio for PCF should be carefully evaluated along with clinical evaluation and other laboratory methods.