Projecting the fiscal impact of immigration in the European Union

Abstract

The increasing flow of immigrants into Europe over the last decade has generated a range of considerations in the policy agenda of many receiving countries. One of the main considerations for policymakers and public opinion alike is whether immigrants contribute their 'fair' share to their host country's tax and welfare system. In this paper, we assess the net fiscal impact of intra-EU and extra-EU migration in 27 European Union (EU) Member States. We find that migrants in the EU, on average, contribute more than natives to welfare states. However, when we take an age-specific lifecycle perspective, we find that natives generally show a higher net fiscal contribution than both groups of migrants. Among migrants, extra-EU migrants contribute less than intra-EU migrants. We then use a demographic microsimulation model to project the potential net fiscal impact of migration in the EU into the future. We show that despite the fact that intra-EU migration contributes to reduce the strong negative impact of population ageing, its contribution is not sufficient to offset the negative fiscal consequences.

Moving Up the Social Ladder? Wages of First- and Second-Generation Immigrants from Developing Countries

“…Indeed, good labour market outcomes for the immigrant population accords with a positive net contribution to economic growth and tax base (Christl et al, 2021;OECD 2021). In this regard, although the employment rates of F-G and S-G immigrants from developing countries have been well-documented at the international level (e.g.…”

Economic and labour market impacts of migration in Austria: an agent-based modelling approach

“…Evidence on the fiscal impact of immigration on advanced economies is mixed, with differences attributed to the characteristics of migrants such as age, skill level, family situation and country of origin, and features of the host economies such as labour market structure, tax and welfare systems, and legal regimes governing migration (Hennessey & Hagen-Zanker, 2020 ; Christl et al, 2022 ). Various static accounting studies indicate either slightly positive or slightly negative fiscal effects of migration, overall converging to fiscal neutrality (Preston, 2014 ).…”

Economic and Labour Market Impacts of Migration in Austria: An Agent-Based Modelling Approach

“…Evidence on the fiscal impact of immigration on advanced economies is mixed, with differences attributed to the characteristics of migrants such as age, skill level, family situation and country of origin, and features of the host economies such as labour market structure, tax and welfare systems, and legal regimes governing migration (Hennessey & Hagen-Zanker, 2020;Christl et al, 2022). Various static accounting studies indicate either slightly positive or slightly negative fiscal effects of migration, overall converging to fiscal neutrality (Preston, 2014).…”