Promoting critical thinking and collaborative working through assessment: combining patchwork text and online discussion boards

Abstract

Within a globalised world that has ever changing social, economic, cultural and legal influences, higher education providers have a responsibility to equip graduates with the skills necessary to meet these demands. Pedagogic research shows that students' motivation is often driven by assessment and therefore the challenge for programmes is to find an assessment method that both assesses and encourages the development of these diverse skills set. We propose that the use of patchwork text combined with online discussion boards can facilitate critical thinking and collaborative working. This paper aims to report on the educational benefits of this combination of assessment methods to promote higher level thinking, and details the nature of the collaboration and outcomes of the assessment, providing guidance for future practise.

Cognitive Presence in a Blended Learning Environment at Jordanian Universities

“…Cognitive presence was defined by Garrison et al (2000Garrison et al ( , 2001 as constructing meaning through sustained and permanent communication. Based on this definition, Matheson, Wilkinson, and Gilhooly, (2012) argue that this could be achieved through "greater use of group work that values the personal contribution and promotes secure learning environments to foster exchange. "(p.259) Two critical issues must be taken into consideration concerning active learning.…”

Chinese business students’ changes in beliefs and strategy use in a constructively aligned PBL course

“…Another notable feature of innovative assessment practices in PBL instruction is the engaging of students in peer assessment to develop critical thinking, self-directed learning, and social metacognition (Matheson, Wilkinson, and Gilhooly 2012). Some claim that employing assessment rubrics and criteria as learning guidance is useful in enhancing students' engagement (Carless 2006;Norton 2004).…”

Cognitive presence through social and teaching presence in communities of inquiry: A correlational–predictive study

“…Integrating the public and private worlds of students is thus a basic concept in the creation of cognitive presence for educational ends. Garrison et al (2000Garrison et al ( , 2001 define cognitive presence as the construction of meaning through sustained and permanent communication, which is achieved through greater use of group work that values the personal contribution and promotes secure learning environments to foster exchange (Matheson, Wilkinson, & Gilhooly, 2012).…”