Promoting Foreign Language Learners’ Writing: Comparing the Impact of Oral Conferencing and Collaborative Writing

Abstract

Abstract-This study was an attempt to compare the effect of oral conferencing alongside collaborative writing on writing ability of English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners. For this purpose, a piloted sample of the Preliminary English Test (PET) was administered to 90 intermediate female EFL learners, between 20 and 32 years old (M age = 26). The results of this test enabled the researchers to select 60 homogenous individuals who were then randomly assigned into two experimental groups of 30 named "oral conferencing group" and "collaborative writing group". To ensure the homogeneity among the participants in terms of their writing ability before the treatment, their scores on the writing section of the PET test were analyzed in isolation and it was considered as the pretest of the study. Oral conferencing included the discussions and negotiations among the participants and the teacher before and after writing activities followed by live teacher-student as well as student-student feedbacks. In the collaborative writing group, the participants wrote compositions in groups based on the same topics introduced in the oral conferencing group. At the end, both experimental groups were given another piloted writing section of the PET test as the posttest. The analysis of the test scores using an independent samples t-test and analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) revealed that there is a significant difference between the effect of oral conferencing and collaborative writing on EFL learners' writing ability. It was concluded that the ability of EFL learners' writing was more affected by applying oral conferencing rather than collaborative writing.

Syllabus Design for Writing Course: EFL Learners’ Needs

“…In accordance with the statement above, Abbas & Herdi (2018), Nosratinia & Nikpanjeh (2019), and Agustiana (2016) also stated that writing skill is more difficult skill than the other three language skills, namely speaking skill, listening skill, and reading skill as previously described. There are two aspects that need to be seriously considered by the writers before they start their writing.…”

The Development of Writing Module on Enhancing the Writing Skills of Omani General Foundation Program Students

“…The module helped students to work collaboratively to carry out various writing tasks. Collaborative writing activities helped students share knowledge and learn from their peers (Saparuddin, Prasetyo & Mahanal, 2018;Jeroen Janssen & Wubbels, 2018;Bikowski & Vithanage, 2016;Dowse & Rensburg, 2015;Khatib, 2015;Nosratinia & Nikpanjeh, 2015;Yeh, 2014). Peer-editing was of substantial significance in the module.…”

“…This theory is pertinent to the current study because it substantiates the fundamental significance of collaboration in the writing classroom where students exchange meaning, knowledge, and learn from peers. Thus, it can be inferred that students learn best when they collaborate with their peers (Saparuddin, Prasetyo & Mahanal, 2018;Jeroen Janssen & Wubbels, 2018;Bikowski & Vithanage, 2016;Dowse & Rensburg, 2015;Khatib, 2015;Nosratinia & Nikpanjeh, 2015;Yeh, 2014). Since the study aimed to improve students' writing ability by adopting the genre approach, Vygotsky's theory is relevant to the study.…”