Promoting Informed Choice: Transforming Health Care To Dispense Knowledge for Decision Making

Abstract

Ours is an era in which patients seek greater engagement in health care choices, increasing the demand for high-quality information about clinical options. Providing support for informed choice is not straightforward, however, because of challenges faced by clinicians, health systems, and consumers. Greater use of written or electronic tools can help to clarify choices for patients, but decision aids cannot replace the human element in facilitating informed choice. The ideal solution is to couple information with high-quality decision counseling to help patients understand the potential risks, benefits, and uncertainties of clinical options and to assist them in selecting the option that best accommodates their personal preferences. Decision counseling can be offered by 3 types of providers: clinicians who lack formal informed-choice training ("usual care"), clinicians with formal informed-choice training, or trained third parties who function as impartial decision counselors. Controlled studies are needed to determine which model is best, but none appears to be ideal. The health care system cannot truly support informed decision making without correcting the underlying obstacles that impede patient access to needed information. New information technology solutions, training programs, and reimbursement schemes are necessary. Patient demand for guidance will only increase as clinical options multiply and the world of information continues its rapid growth. Today's health care system is unprepared for the convergence of these 2 burgeoning domains, and the need to address systemic deficiencies will grow more urgent over time.

A Randomized Trial of a Prenatal Genetic Testing Interactive Computerized Information Aid

“…9 Information and decision aids have been recommended for use in clinical situations in which patient education is necessary for fully informed decision-making. [10][11][12][13] Use of decision aids for prenatal counseling using structured, paper-based or basic electronic tools has been associated with less decision conflict, improved knowledge, and in some cases, increased uptake of prenatal testing. [14][15][16][17][18] Such tools can facilitate an improved informed consent process, yet few decision aids have been developed and evaluated in the United States, particularly for use in low literacy populations.…”

Have ALLHAT, ANBP2, ASCOT-BPLA, and So Forth Improved Our Knowledge About Better Hypertension Care?

“…35,36 Structured teaching and treatment programs aiming at better control in treated patients have been conducted previously. 37 The results of these new ways to improve the quality of hypertension care are promising, but there is still a lack of evidence about the optimal way to provide adequate care.…”

Strategies for Radiology Reporting and Communication Part 3: Patient Communication and Education

“…At the forefront of these changes is the patient who has become increasingly empowered and is now demanding greater access to their healthcare data and involvement in decision-making [1][2][3]. While radiology practice has traditionally limited communication of medical imaging report data between radiologists and referring clinicians, increasing emphasis is being placed on direct radiologistpatient communication, which has been mandated in breast imaging with the passage of the Mammography Quality Standards Act (MQSA) [4].…”