Prostate magnetic resonance imaging‐targeted biopsy global grade correlates better than highest grade with prostatectomy grade

Abstract

Background Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)‐targeted prostate biopsy has become an increasingly common method of diagnosing prostate cancer. A previous study from our institution demonstrated that the biopsy global Grade Group (gGG, aggregate GG of all positive cores) and highest Grade Group (hGG in any core) both show substantial concordance with the Grade Group at radical prostatectomy (RPGG) while the discordance predominantly consists of upgrading in gGG and downgrading in hGG. We performed a larger cohort study focused on biopsy cases in which gGG and hGG differ, to determine their relative concordance with RPGG. Methods We conducted a retrospective review of radical prostatectomy specimens with prior MRI‐targeted biopsies from our institution between 2016 and 2020. Separate gGG and hGG were assigned to each MRI‐targeted lesion. Targeted lesions with different gGG versus hGG were segregated from those with identical gGG and hGG. The concordance of biopsy GG with RPGG was evaluated using κ coefficient analysis. Results Of the 489 lesions with MRI‐targeted biopsies, 82 (17%) differed in gGG versus hGG. The gGG of 46 (56%), 33 (40%), and 3 (4%) lesions were unchanged, upgraded, and downgraded at radical prostatectomy, respectively (κ= 0.302, weighted κ = 0.334). The hGG of 24 (29%), 9 (11%), and 49 (60%) lesions were unchanged, upgraded, and downgraded at radical prostatectomy, respectively (κ = 0.040, weighted κ = 0.198). When stratified by the biopsy GG, gGG showed the highest concordance in GG2 (61%) and GG3 (54%) lesions. The hGG resulted in substantial downgrading (60%) with less optimal concordance regardless of the biopsy GG. Neither the prebiopsy prostate specific antigen level nor the PI‐RADS score was predictive of upgrading of gGG. Conclusions When gGG and hGG differ, gGG method more accurately predicts the RPGG than hGG, particularly in GG2 and GG3 lesions which comprised the majority of targeted lesions.

Expected impact of MRI-targeted biopsy interreader variability among uropathologists on ProScreen prostate cancer screening trial: a pre-trial validation study

“…Our study is the first to evaluate the interobserver agreement of multiple pathologists on MRI-targeted diagnostic prostate biopsies. Assessing a lesion-wise aggregate GG has been shown to correlate better with RP GG than core-wise highest GG [ 30 ], which again emphasizes the need to adhere to reporting guidelines.…”